Would you sleep in a smokers' room?
#1
Original Poster
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 218
Likes: 0
Would you sleep in a smokers' room?
Non-smokers: I have the opportunity of staying in a pretty good boutique hotel- the location is in a good place, the room looks attractive, breakfast is included and it's a great discounted room rate. The only problem is that the room is a smokers' room. As a non-smoker, would you still stay there or is it enough for you to give it a miss?
#6


Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 9,304
Likes: 0
ehhhhh... your stuff would smell like smoke for days.
On the other hand, MAYBE if you booked the smokers room and arrived and they had a last minute cancellation you'd luck out and get a nonsmoking room. You'd be taking a chance.
If this is a boutique hotel, it's probably very clean and well kept so perhaps they do a better job of ridding the room of the smoke smell. Also, if it has a balcony I'd be willing to bet a number of smokers step outside anyway. I dunno. I'd have to be totally in love with the hotel and location to take the chance.
On the other hand, MAYBE if you booked the smokers room and arrived and they had a last minute cancellation you'd luck out and get a nonsmoking room. You'd be taking a chance.
If this is a boutique hotel, it's probably very clean and well kept so perhaps they do a better job of ridding the room of the smoke smell. Also, if it has a balcony I'd be willing to bet a number of smokers step outside anyway. I dunno. I'd have to be totally in love with the hotel and location to take the chance.
Trending Topics
#8
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 26,390
Likes: 0
I agree with flygirl. I don't smoke but if the room had other options that made it attractive and it was clean. I would take it. In some countries and states in the US, people smoke wherever they want and sometimes they smoke in non smoking rooms. Usually it's cleaned up.
Only you know how much it would bother you.
Only you know how much it would bother you.
#9
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 5,142
Likes: 0
No way. Last week I stayed in the Westin Back Bay in Boston and we were offered an upgrade to a junior suite with river views. The room was lovely but it smelt of smoke (in a smoke free hotel!!!) so we quickly downgraded to a regular room.
#10
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,521
Likes: 0
No. I've had to do it on rare occasions, most recently in Singapore, when my flight from Tokyo arrived well after midnight and the hotel could only give me a smoking room with the promise to move me the next day. The room was was foul: not just the smell of stale smoke, but the general griminess that comes with it. I didn't bother to even open my suitcase, and waited to shower until I'd been moved to a new room.
My new room was lovely, bright, clean, and fresh-smelling.
My new room was lovely, bright, clean, and fresh-smelling.
#11
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 124
Likes: 0
No, no, no!
I stayed at the Wangfujing Grand Hotel in Beijing and was unfortunately assigned a smokers room. As soon as I opened the door the stench of stale cigarette smoke hit me.
Everything absorbs the odour; carpet, bedding, soft furnishings, everything! The next morning my hair was stinky as were my pyjamas. I'm just glad I didn't leave my suitcase open that night. I was able to transfer to a non smoking room...which just so happened to be in another hotel.
I stayed at the Wangfujing Grand Hotel in Beijing and was unfortunately assigned a smokers room. As soon as I opened the door the stench of stale cigarette smoke hit me.
Everything absorbs the odour; carpet, bedding, soft furnishings, everything! The next morning my hair was stinky as were my pyjamas. I'm just glad I didn't leave my suitcase open that night. I was able to transfer to a non smoking room...which just so happened to be in another hotel.
#12
Original Poster
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 218
Likes: 0
I ended up not booking the room, and checking in at a more inexpensive (but inferior) hotel. Thing was, although I could have sworn I booked a non-smoking room, I am sure my nose twigged on something not quite right. There was something faintly noxious, but it wasn't obvious.
#13
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
I couldn't no matter what the options are; my wife wouldn't be able to either. If you arrived unannounced at a hotel, you'd have the chance of taking a look (and smell) first; in this situation you don't have that option. Only you can know how it affects you.
#14
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
I'm curious as to why you are asking total strangers on the internet a question which only you can answer. Your preferences in where you stay or choose, what you smell or eat are yours alone. All we can do is offer opinions based on OUR OWN experiences and/or preferences. We don't know what drives you to your decisions over such deeply personal things. Are you wanting to "flame" smokers? Kind of reminds me of asking a previously unknown policeman if he wears boxers or briefs.
#16
Original Poster
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 218
Likes: 0
Hi Salina. My response would be that I am asking experienced members of this forum as to their experiences in this kind of situation. he question wasn't just "would you sleep in a smoking room if you are a non-smoker" but also "at what price would you sleep in a smoking room if you are a non-smoker". For the majority of people who replied, the answer is not at any price.
BTW, I wasn't being anti-smoker at all when I asked this question.
BTW, I wasn't being anti-smoker at all when I asked this question.
#17
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 10
Likes: 0
No. Been there done that, regretted it. You probably would, too. That room, being a designated "smoking room" probably gets smoked in every single night. It's gonna reek.
salina5 needs to loosen the necktie just a bit, me thinks.
salina5 needs to loosen the necktie just a bit, me thinks.
Thread
Original Poster
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Tiff
Europe
17
Apr 12th, 2007 10:26 AM



