Fodorite Poll - Weigh in on your Maui dinner faves:

Mama's Fish House?
Nick's Fishmarket?
Sarento's?
David Paul's Lahaina Grill?
IO?
Plantation House?
Hula Grill?
Pacific'O?
Haliimaile General Store?

all those are good choices. I would rate Nick's as my FAV. The best dinner experience of my life was at Nick's YUM

Kay

Two of my favorites didn't make the list, so I thought I would add them on;
Kobe Steak House and Bubba Gumps.
Yumm Yumm.

The best nice/expensive meal is Nick's.
The best affordable/casual meal is Sensei (awesome sushi too!!)

Mama's

Nick's hands down!

Consistantly good food or overpriced, touristy, pay-for-the-waterfront-and-big-marketing-budget restaurants?

Consider trying:
Capische
Seawatch (actually has best view of all the south Maui restaurants)
Maalaea Waterfront
Café Sauvage
Chez Paul

If I had to pick from your list: Plantation House, I`o, Pacific`O, in that order.