Well...I've decided to stay the 8 nights at Robert's Grove....my husband really wanted a pool and neither of us wanted to see a kitchen during our vacation---so that narrowed down our choices, from what I could tell, to Robert's Grove or Victoria House (I guess Turtle Inn also- but there website isn't really that informative) ... I sent them both emails and VH never responded, which was a BIG turn off. On the other hand Risa at Robert's Grove has responded to all of my inquires almost immediately and has went out of her way to send me additional pictures and such on items I had questions about. So, Risa's responsiveness has really sold me!

Robert's Grove is excellent BUT I strongly recommend you opt for one of the deluxe suites (they have one-bedroom and two-bedroom suites). The regular rooms and the older junior suites are not five-star, whereas the newer deluxe suites are.

Having stayed at both Robert's Grove (several times) and Turtle Inn, I like them both. My kids prefer Turtle Inn's pool, the main one, which is a fantastic zero effect pool. But I like the air-conditioning, in-room phones and cable TV at Robert's Grove.

--Lan Sluder