Now we have choices for budget hotels in NYC for April stay for two seniors and a granddaughter What do you suggest about the following:

Manhattan Broadway Hotel
Grand Union Hotel
Portland Square Hotel
New York Inn
Pickwick Arms Hotel
Washington Jefferson Hotel
Or others?

Thanks again for your help.

ttt

I don't know if you've done a search on this forum yet but there's 2 different ways. Since you've got the names of some hotels you're interested in, just type the name (one at a time) in the text box and hit enter. That'll pull up any posting with that hotel name in it. Do that for all the hotels you listed. The other way is to click on the "hotel" button at the top of the screen, find NY, then dearch for the hotels in alphabetical order. You'll see ratings and reviews posted by people who stayed there.

Hope that helps. Have fun, we're going in Sept. with my 14 yr old and staying at the Avalon.

Check out the Comfort Inn MIDTOWN. Very convenient location, recently renovated, very clean and comfortable, I got it for $89 per night.

I have only stayed at Pickwick Arms so I can't compare to the others. However, it was a nice place to stay and I would return there.

I just posted a reply for someone with the title of "hotel help" in nyc. Check out www.hospitalityco.com on nyc accomodations. It may interest you.

These are helpful suggestions but it seems the Comptons may have already taken this trip as the original post is 2 years old.

Oh, I'm completely MORTIFIED, I usually catch those things!

wow. I didn't even think to look at the date! Very funny "xxx".

The original post may be old but I just learned something NEW! I've been coming on this board for a few years and I've NEVER seen the search for HOTEL. My, my, my....