Need 3BR NYC vacation rental
#22
Original Poster
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 7,142
Likes: 0
Michelle,
Thanks, but ...
I didn't say "no object" - I said the not the "driving factor".
Twelve thousand dollars per night is, I'm afraid, an "object". Twelve hundred dollars per night for a hotel suite (though we've always went with apts) is more realistic - and really more of a last resort price for us.
Thanks, but ...
I didn't say "no object" - I said the not the "driving factor".
Twelve thousand dollars per night is, I'm afraid, an "object". Twelve hundred dollars per night for a hotel suite (though we've always went with apts) is more realistic - and really more of a last resort price for us.
#23
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,886
Likes: 0
Doug -
I think you're mistaken - there are tons of 3 bedrooms apartments in Manhattan - esp in prewar buildings. Most of my friend with kids have 3 bedrooms (the so-called "classic 6" by realtors).
But, they're usually family apartments and rarely are they for sublet - esp short term.
And, for obvious reasons, corporate or even vacation rentals are usually one bedrooms at most.
So - agree finding a short-term 3 bedroom rental is very unlikely.
I think you're mistaken - there are tons of 3 bedrooms apartments in Manhattan - esp in prewar buildings. Most of my friend with kids have 3 bedrooms (the so-called "classic 6" by realtors).
But, they're usually family apartments and rarely are they for sublet - esp short term.
And, for obvious reasons, corporate or even vacation rentals are usually one bedrooms at most.
So - agree finding a short-term 3 bedroom rental is very unlikely.
#25
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 10,210
Likes: 0
There may be 5,000 3-bedroom apartments in Manhattan, virtually all of them occupied with renters/owners. There are over 1 million people in Manhattan alone. A handful of those apartments are ever up for short-term rental. Do the math. I'm just trying to be realistic for the poster.
I still think the 2-bedroom suite + 1 regular room is the best they're going to be able to do under the circumstances.
But the Kimberly is a very good suggestion. It's not nearly as deluxe as the Four Seasons, and the location is good as well.
I still think the 2-bedroom suite + 1 regular room is the best they're going to be able to do under the circumstances.
But the Kimberly is a very good suggestion. It's not nearly as deluxe as the Four Seasons, and the location is good as well.
#26
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 16,715
Likes: 0
If you're looking to cook a gourmet meal, I don't think any of the typical suite hotels will give you either the space or equipment you'd want, but I would start by contacting Affinia to see if they do have any 3 bedroom suites or whether any 2 suites could be attached.
This looks closer to what you'd want but I have no personal info about whether it's legit etc.
http://www.vrbo.com/117521
This looks closer to what you'd want but I have no personal info about whether it's legit etc.
http://www.vrbo.com/117521
#27
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,886
Likes: 0
Sorry - I can't imagine any short term rental that would be equipped to cook a gourmet meal. Even a corporate rental with a regular kitchen simply doesn't have the equipment you would need. They have just the bare basics - assuming it's people that will order in or micro nuke stuff, except for snacks or breakfast.
As for the classic 6 - it depends on how old the building is. Many are true family apartments - and the 6 doesn't count a maid's room. Usually you can get a double bed - true, not a whole lot more - in the third bedroom as long as it's 60's or before. It's the newer buildings that have the closet third bedrooms. Or - just the faking of a real estate agent.
As for the classic 6 - it depends on how old the building is. Many are true family apartments - and the 6 doesn't count a maid's room. Usually you can get a double bed - true, not a whole lot more - in the third bedroom as long as it's 60's or before. It's the newer buildings that have the closet third bedrooms. Or - just the faking of a real estate agent.
#28
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 36,842
Likes: 0
I'm not sure what kind of short term rental we're talking about here, but I've rented five or six short term rental apartments in NYC, and although I didn't do any real cooking, I sure could have. Most of them came with everything from mixers and processors to about every kind of pan and cookware you might want, rolling pins, utensils, graters, coffee bean grinders, espresso makers, you name it. All have had full sized ranges with ovens and four burners. Unless the poster is expecting a 6 burner Viking with rotisserie and grill, I can't imagine struggling too much. On the other hand if you're talking about an "apartment hotel" like an Affina one, rather than a regular apartment, then I suppose the microwave, limited cooking thing might be true.
The three bedroom matter, however, is quite a different thing!
The three bedroom matter, however, is quite a different thing!


>-


