Go Back  Fodor's Forum > Destinations > United States
Reload this Page > help me plan my 1st trip to NYC. need suggestions, info & advice.

help me plan my 1st trip to NYC. need suggestions, info & advice.


Oct 18th, 2012, 05:30 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 105
help me plan my 1st trip to NYC. need suggestions, info & advice.

Ive never been to NYC before and am going sometime in 2013. (i have no specific dates set, and likewise am very flexible schedule-wise, but would like to go when whether isnt freezing cold....sweater weather..50Fs-ish or warmer)

I wont have a rental car, but as Im told, its not a neccessity in NYC, and in most cases nor is it recommended.

I would like to stay about 5 or 6 nights, and will be flying into Newark Intl., Id like to find a decent hotel around $100 a night, that preferably offers transit to/from both the airport and the local PATH train station. ( a friend recommended me to the Best Western Newark Airport West located at 101 International Way in Newark directly adjacent to the airport, but I am open to other similiar lodging options)

As far as mass transit, I do have questions about both the PATH and MTA, from what I understand they are completely seperate transit systems and independent from each other, and require their own respective passes. Where do I buy each pass? and does either pass have the available option to buy a more premier pass that includes local entertainment/attraction options?

As far as attractions, I know NYC has an endless myriad of options. I know Id definitely like to see: Statue of Liberty, Brooklyn Bridge, Times Square, Hard Rock Cafe, Chinatown, Little Italy, Central Park, WTC site, Empire State Bldg.

Not really interested in Broadway shows, in case someone reading this may wonder if I forgot to mention it.

As far as cuisine: Id mostly interested in sampling whatever is locally heralded as being some of the best in both Little Italy and Chinatown,..and should I venture into Brooklyn to satisfy my cravings for classic New York Italian or does Little Italy suffice this?

I am also eager for any other suggestions for restaurants that I must try, whatever is locally acclaimed as being "must-have".

Im under the impression that most tourists seldom ever venture into the other 4 boroughs and only visit Manhattan...Im also under the impression that Manhattan is the safest borough for tourists to visit. Is it worth visiting any of the other boroughs? should some boroughs or neighborhoods be avoided at all costs due to rampant crime problems, and if so, what areas should I avoid? If some areas are worth the visit, what should I visit?

Im also under the impression that Staten Island is mostly a residential island, and offers little for the tourist to see or do? true?

Ive heard the Ellis Island has its own amusement park similiar to Coney Island. Does it rival C.I. in anyway? should I visit one versus the other?

How would you plan my trip out as far as the aforementioned ideas I have thus far? What should I do and see on each day of my intenerary? Is my stay sufficient, or should I increase it to more days?

Please feel free to suggest me to anything, and correct me on anything I may be wrong about.
osakaorchid is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 05:35 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 105
Id also like to be recommended to musuems. Ive heard MOMA is one of the best. Are there others I should visit?
osakaorchid is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 06:13 PM
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 24,163
Two specifics:

Ellis Island is a museum chronicling the history of immigration to the United States - most immigrants from Europe in the early part of the 20th century were processed through Ellis Island. It is not an amusement park at all, but it is a fascinating museum.

Yes, Staten Island is a residential borough with nothing of interest to tourists. There are parts of Brroklyn, the Bronx and Queens that might be of interest to tourists. For example, Flushing in Queens has a plethora of Chinese restaurants which some consider to be the best in the city, and The Bronx has Arthur Ave. (better than Little Italy for Italian food), the Bronx Zoo, the Bronx Botanical Garden. The Cloisters is also up toward the Bronx, although it's still in Manhattan. Brooklyn has a variety of interesting neighborhoods.

I don't know if it's possible to find a $100 per night hotel in NY, except perhaps in January or February (and even then not likely) which are the worst weather months (far below your desired 50°+).
sf7307 is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 06:49 PM
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 105
Ive done some light research on hotels, not in NY but in Newark, NJ. Ive decided to stay in Newark and transit via PATH/MTA each day of my visit due to the substantially cheaper lodging rates.

Id like to stay at a hotel that's either within walking distance of Penn Station in Newark, or provides transit to/from Penn Station in Newark back to my hotel, and preferably also to/from Newark Intl Airport.
osakaorchid is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 06:57 PM
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,469
PATH trains do not operate from Newark or the airport. You would have to take a bus to another train (NJ transit)into Manhattan or a bus to get to PATH ,then MTA transit within NYC. Time and money can add up if you do this over several days.

Many hotels in Newark are in unpleasant areas. I doubt there's anything in safe "walking distance" to transit to NYC. It's common for people to try to save money on the expensive NYC hotel rates, but what you plan to do would not be something most of us would recommend, and there will no doubt many more warnings or arguments to convince you to change your plans
nyer is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 07:15 PM
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 9,895
I hope you enjoy NYC. You have some misconceptions about the city, but many first-time visitors do.

First, PATH trains do operate from Newark, but it's a pretty long ride (perhaps over 30 minutes each way), and they do not run all night, nor very frequently at all at night (this mean that it may take you over an hour to get back to your hotel if you're not near the PATH station in Manhattan). It's certainly possible to stay in downtown Newark, but I'm only aware of 2 hotels. There's a Hilton attached to Newark Penn, but it's going to cost considerably more than $100 at most times of the year (and by next year, I think there's virtually no chance you'll find one anywhere). And there's the Robert Treat Hotel, which is probably your only alternative (though it also may be more than $100). But hotels close to the airport are particularly inconvenient, and while they have cheap rates, you have to pay $12 to get into the city from the airport, and most of these hotels have free shuttles that run on relatively limited schedules.

I think you'll find a lot to like in Brooklyn. It's one of the most dynamic areas of NYC and has a great restaurant scene as well as art galleries and alot of interest shops. There are a lot of cool neighborhoods there, and some are every bit as safe as Manhattan, some less so but still worth exploring. Some are difficult to reach by subway, though (another reason to stay closer to the city).

I'd also caution that Newark is one of the more dangerous places around NYC after dark, so just keep that in mind. You'll want to do all your going out and dining in Manhattan and then just keep your head down and go straight back to the hotel. If it were me, I'd choose the cheapest room with a private bath (which is in Queens usually which is on the NYC subway system 1 or 2 stops from midtown, so about 5 to 10 minutes rather than an hour). And the area is desolate but safe. These rooms are often around $99 but more usually around $125. You'll probably save enough in terms of time and money to justify staying there. Country INn and Suites Long Island City is generally one of the cheaper options, and it's 1 block from the subway.

NYC doesn't offer any combination tickets that include transit and entertainment, but you can use a regular metro card on both the PATH and subway trains, which cost $2.25 each. So the same card, but you can't get a free transfer from one system to the other.

I do think it's probably far too early to start planning itineraries. I'd suggest you buy a good guidebook to NYC so you won't be confused about so many basic facts (such as the lack of an amusement park on Ellis Island). And then you start trying to decide what interests you and we can help more.
doug_stallings is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 07:19 PM
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,643
PLEASE do not stay at Newark airport - you will spend 2 to 3 hours per day getting to and from Manhattan. It doesn;t matter how cheap this is - it's just not New York. Granted your budget is super low for NYC - if you go in April (NOT easter) you may be able to get something decent in Manhattan via Priceline. (You want to walk out the door and be in Manhattan - just a few minutes walk to some of the sights - not have to wait for a hotel shuttle, take it to the airport, then take AirTrain to the train station, then NJ TRansit to Penn Station). Also if you stay at that hotel - you are stranded at the side of a highway - no way to get to restaurants or shops - and the hotel shuttle might not run late enough for you to eat in the city or enjoy an evening sight and then get back to the hotel.)

There are some budget places in Manhattan where you might find a deal - look at the Jane Hotel (which has some tiny singles) and a few of the others - and when considering the price remember that you don;t have to pay to trek in from Jersey every day.

Elllis Island has a brilliant Immigration Museum - anyone who told you it has an amusement park has never been near it. (And Coney Island, while a NY tradition - for a lot of reasons - is nothing like a modern amusement park - it's style is very 1940s - although the hay day was the 1920s.)

As for what to see and do - there is enough to keep you busy for months. So stay as long as you can - based on your budget. If there is something you really want to see in one of the outer boroughs by all means do it - but not just for the sake of it - when there is so much else going on.

The Met is the greatest cultural institution in the western hemisphere - but look at the website before you go or you can be there in for days - I suggest sticking to 3 or at most 4 departments

MoMA is great if you like modern art (1900 or so on)

Natural History is fantastic as is the adjacent Planetarium

And there are dozens more - on any subject from the Intrepid air and space museum (with space shuttle) to the NY Historical Society to the Tenement Museum to the Asia Society to the Museum of Sex.

As for Italian food - little Italy is essentially gone - and there are few restaurants there worth eating at. The most traditional Italian is in the Bronx (Arthur Ave) but there are plenty of great Italian places in Manhattan - at all price points.

For other restaurants - you need to tell us what cuisines you like/dislike and a budget (based on your hotel budget you should probably look at very modest restaurants).
nytraveler is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 07:59 PM
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 313
"PATH and MTA, from what I understand they are completely seperate transit systems"

MTA is the system in NYC(buses, subways).

"Where do I buy each pass?"

metrocards are sold in every station. Get a $10 one.

"As far as attractions, Hard Rock Cafe"

I dont think it's around anymore.

"should I venture into Brooklyn to satisfy my cravings"

Yes, go to Brighton Beach, Emmons ave, Coney Island ave, 86st.

"Ive heard the Ellis Island has its own amusement park similiar to Coney Island. "

huh? where did u hear that? was it an April Fool's joke?
POMAH is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 18th, 2012, 08:06 PM
Join Date: Aug 2012
Posts: 444
Friends often stay in hotels in Long Island City to save some money. Perhaps it's time to get a good guidebook and just go over the basics before you start planning meals, etc.?
EmilyPost is offline  
Reply With Quote
Oct 19th, 2012, 05:25 AM
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,643
You need to understand that major parts of Newark are extremely high crime areas and this is NOT where you want to stay. As in you don;t want to be on the street during daytime, never mind at night. This is why they are so shockingly cheap.

There are places in NJ that have relatively good access to Manhattan - as in Jersey City right on top of the PATH train - but they typically are very little less expensive than Manhattan. An place in Jersey that is much cheaper is typically because the commute into NYC is difficult and expesnive - as in bus to train or PATH taking hours out of your day and at substantial cost.

Much better to find a budget place in Manhattan - and not waste all that time and money going back and forth.
nytraveler is offline  
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On

All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:02 AM.