What is the difference - Munich station question
#1
Original Poster
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,654
Likes: 0
What is the difference - Munich station question
Right, I am ready to book seats from Munich to Paris return. Although I clicked on the ENGLISH version the schedule still is in German and I need to clarify the following:
What is the diff between Flughaven Terminalbereich A/B and Munchen Flughaven Terminal ?
What is Munchen - Liam and Munchen Pasing?
What is the diff between Flughaven Terminalbereich A/B and Munchen Flughaven Terminal ?
What is Munchen - Liam and Munchen Pasing?
#2
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 9,023
Likes: 0
Passing is a S-Bahn station
Flughaven means airport
you really only want to book Munich Hauptbahnhof to Paris i think for online discounts - there is only one train station at Munich Airport but the trains take two different routes to the Hauptbahnhof - two different S-Bahn lines taking about the same time. this could explain the A/B - A for one route and B for the other?
Flughaven means airport
you really only want to book Munich Hauptbahnhof to Paris i think for online discounts - there is only one train station at Munich Airport but the trains take two different routes to the Hauptbahnhof - two different S-Bahn lines taking about the same time. this could explain the A/B - A for one route and B for the other?
#3
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 556
Likes: 0
I am not sure what schedule you are looking at. When I look at the rail schedule I only see Munchen Hbf (Hauptbahnhof) to Paris Est.
The S-Bahn from the airport is either Line S1 or S8 to Hauptbahnhof. Both lines will get you there and you do not need to purchase a ticket in advance for this. There are machines right by the track.
The S-Bahn from the airport is either Line S1 or S8 to Hauptbahnhof. Both lines will get you there and you do not need to purchase a ticket in advance for this. There are machines right by the track.
#4
Original Poster
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,654
Likes: 0
Lynnaustin & Palenque , I am looking at the schedule for July 22nd going to Paris not earlier than 9.24 and returning in August 27th. For the retun date we have decided on the 9.00+- departure with that scarey dash at Stuttgart between platforms.
It was when I was looking at the Munich/Paris schedule that some of the options showed names of places I thought may cause a problem.
I feel sure my booking will be OK now- thanks!
It was when I was looking at the Munich/Paris schedule that some of the options showed names of places I thought may cause a problem.
I feel sure my booking will be OK now- thanks!
#5
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 9,023
Likes: 0
München Hbf Th, 22.07.10 dep 10:23 14 ICE 598 Intercity-Express
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 arr 12:47 10
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 dep 12:54 9 TGV 9574
Paris Est Th, 22.07.10 arr 16:34
First train looks like the 10:23 and with 7 mins in Stuttgart to go to the train awaiting on the very next platform - that tells me it is probably a coordinated change where if the train from Munich is a bit late the TGV will wait for it - i would not sweat that connection very much.
I think it may be for technical reasons the TGV can only start at Stuttgart but not sure.
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 arr 12:47 10
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 dep 12:54 9 TGV 9574
Paris Est Th, 22.07.10 arr 16:34
First train looks like the 10:23 and with 7 mins in Stuttgart to go to the train awaiting on the very next platform - that tells me it is probably a coordinated change where if the train from Munich is a bit late the TGV will wait for it - i would not sweat that connection very much.
I think it may be for technical reasons the TGV can only start at Stuttgart but not sure.
#6
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 8,247
Likes: 0
As the others have said, the only relevant station for you is München Hauptbahnhof (or Hbf), which means Central Station.
München-Pasing is a station on the Western edge where also many long-distance trains call.
München-Laim is a suburban train station only.
The different airport stops are not all suburban train stations but also bus stops. With bahn.de you can also get connections to bus stops, so that's why you often see a lot of potential stops as destinations.
If you travel on a saver fare or are otherwise restricted to specific trains and you should miss your dedicated connection in Stuttgart due to late arrival from Paris, see the passenger information in the main hall ("Info Point") to get a remark on your ticket. You will be able to use the next train, which run frequently (at least one per hour).
München-Pasing is a station on the Western edge where also many long-distance trains call.
München-Laim is a suburban train station only.
The different airport stops are not all suburban train stations but also bus stops. With bahn.de you can also get connections to bus stops, so that's why you often see a lot of potential stops as destinations.
If you travel on a saver fare or are otherwise restricted to specific trains and you should miss your dedicated connection in Stuttgart due to late arrival from Paris, see the passenger information in the main hall ("Info Point") to get a remark on your ticket. You will be able to use the next train, which run frequently (at least one per hour).
#7
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 9,016
Likes: 0
I resent the statement that Pasing, the Munich distict I was born in, is a train station. It was a town, long before trains even existed. Laim too is a Munich district and not an S-Bahn station! 
And Flughafen is spelled with "f".

And Flughafen is spelled with "f".
Trending Topics
#11
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,271
Likes: 0
I have done that exact connection each of the last 2 summers and the ICE train arriving in Stuttgart was on time to the minute and it is an across the platform transfer...off the ICE onto the TGV takes 30 seconds...I wouldn't worry...indeed it is Munich Hbf which is the main station....the ICE train originates from there and the actual train arrives about 15 minutes before departure giving you plenty of time to get on it with no hassle whatsoever.....
#12
Original Poster
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,654
Likes: 0
Cowboy & everyone - Firstly I am releived to know that we can have our tickets remarked should we miss our connection. I hope they don't charge extra as we are getting this special internet rate for booking early!
Here are my proposed bookings:
MUNICH to PARIS
München Flughafen Terminal Th, 22.07.10 dep 09:33 1 S 1 S-Bahn Direction: München Ost
München-Laim Th, 22.07.10 arr 10:08 2
München-Laim Th, 22.07.10 dep 10:13 1 S 8 S-Bahn
München-Pasing Th, 22.07.10 arr 10:15 6/7
München-Pasing Th, 22.07.10 dep 10:31 9 ICE 598 Intercity-Express
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 arr 12:47 10
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 dep 12:54 9 TGV 9574 TGV
Paris Est Th, 22.07.10 arr 16:34
As you can see this is where I got confused about Munchen-Pasing & Munchen Liam>
RETURN JOURNEY Paris to Munich:
Paris Est Fr, 27.08.10 dep 09:09 TGV 9553 TGV
Mannheim Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 12:14 3
Mannheim Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 dep 12:30 5 ICE 595 Intercity-Express
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 15:33 14
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 walk 10 min.
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10 dep 15:43 2 S 1 S-Bahn
München Flughafen Terminal Fr, 27.08.10 arr 16:26
Now, this next OPTION VIA STUTTGART with arrival on platform 6 and the ICE connection departing from platform 15! This is where we nearly came unstuck last time:
Paris Est Fr, 27.08.10 dep 11:24 TGV 9573 TGV
Stuttgart Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 15:04 6
Stuttgart Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 dep 15:12 15 ICE 597 Intercity-Express.
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 17:33 14
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 walk 10 min.
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10 dep 17:43 2 S 1 S-Bahn
München Flughafen Terminal Fr, 27.08.10 arr 18:26
I would appreciate anyone pointing out any hitches or give me some advice about stations and platforms. Thanks so much.
Here are my proposed bookings:
MUNICH to PARIS
München Flughafen Terminal Th, 22.07.10 dep 09:33 1 S 1 S-Bahn Direction: München Ost
München-Laim Th, 22.07.10 arr 10:08 2
München-Laim Th, 22.07.10 dep 10:13 1 S 8 S-Bahn
München-Pasing Th, 22.07.10 arr 10:15 6/7
München-Pasing Th, 22.07.10 dep 10:31 9 ICE 598 Intercity-Express
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 arr 12:47 10
Stuttgart Hbf Th, 22.07.10 dep 12:54 9 TGV 9574 TGV
Paris Est Th, 22.07.10 arr 16:34
As you can see this is where I got confused about Munchen-Pasing & Munchen Liam>
RETURN JOURNEY Paris to Munich:
Paris Est Fr, 27.08.10 dep 09:09 TGV 9553 TGV
Mannheim Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 12:14 3
Mannheim Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 dep 12:30 5 ICE 595 Intercity-Express
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 15:33 14
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 walk 10 min.
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10 dep 15:43 2 S 1 S-Bahn
München Flughafen Terminal Fr, 27.08.10 arr 16:26
Now, this next OPTION VIA STUTTGART with arrival on platform 6 and the ICE connection departing from platform 15! This is where we nearly came unstuck last time:
Paris Est Fr, 27.08.10 dep 11:24 TGV 9573 TGV
Stuttgart Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 15:04 6
Stuttgart Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 dep 15:12 15 ICE 597 Intercity-Express.
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 arr 17:33 14
München Hbf Fr, 27.08.10 walk 10 min.
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10
München Hbf (tief) Fr, 27.08.10 dep 17:43 2 S 1 S-Bahn
München Flughafen Terminal Fr, 27.08.10 arr 18:26
I would appreciate anyone pointing out any hitches or give me some advice about stations and platforms. Thanks so much.
#14
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 2,206
Likes: 0
If you simply take an S-Bahn earlier you can comfortably change at the HBf (main station) without doing all that mad dashes in Laim and Pasing. The schedule tries to save you time but all it means is inconveniencing you for the sake of 10 min saving.
#15
Original Poster
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,654
Likes: 0
Cowboy - From MUNICH airport to Paris.
Altamiro - I would love to get through customs, pick up our bags and then jump on a train which will get us on the road to Paris! If I book the Laim & Pasing ticket and we find that we can get on a S-Bhan to the HBf, will we be asked to pay again? I don't see any other option on the DBhan schedule.
Altamiro - I would love to get through customs, pick up our bags and then jump on a train which will get us on the road to Paris! If I book the Laim & Pasing ticket and we find that we can get on a S-Bhan to the HBf, will we be asked to pay again? I don't see any other option on the DBhan schedule.
#16
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 8,247
Likes: 0
tod..
Munich airport has NO long-distance train station. All trains departing from Munich airport are suburban trains (S-Bahn). When you buy a ticket from Munich airport to Paris, the S-Bahn ride to Munich Central station is included.
Please forget the Laim/Pasing option: It's the *shortest* connection which in this sense means that you may save 5 or 6 minutes compared with a change at Munich Central. But: You have stairs only to change platforms at Laim and Pasing, so simply forget this option no matter what the website tells you.
Take ANY train leaving Munich airport (S1 or S8).
Get off at Munich Central (Hauptbahnhof)
Take escalators two levels up to the main hall (signs, also in English, will guide you towards "long distance trains").
And, unless taking the train has a certain sightseeing benefit for you, have you checked flights from Munich to Paris? airberlin.com might have good fares, also o/w only.
Munich airport has NO long-distance train station. All trains departing from Munich airport are suburban trains (S-Bahn). When you buy a ticket from Munich airport to Paris, the S-Bahn ride to Munich Central station is included.
Please forget the Laim/Pasing option: It's the *shortest* connection which in this sense means that you may save 5 or 6 minutes compared with a change at Munich Central. But: You have stairs only to change platforms at Laim and Pasing, so simply forget this option no matter what the website tells you.
Take ANY train leaving Munich airport (S1 or S8).
Get off at Munich Central (Hauptbahnhof)
Take escalators two levels up to the main hall (signs, also in English, will guide you towards "long distance trains").
And, unless taking the train has a certain sightseeing benefit for you, have you checked flights from Munich to Paris? airberlin.com might have good fares, also o/w only.
#17
Original Poster
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 3,654
Likes: 0
Right, we will jump on the S-Bhan as soon as we are through with all the formalties at Munich Airport. Once at Munich central station we will board(or wait for) our designated train for Paris - changing at Stuttgart.
The advice about Munich Liam & Pasing was invaluable Cowboy- once again am so pleased to be a member of the Fodorite family! All you have to do is ask.....even if the questions seem dumb at the time.
My heartfelt thanks to all of you,
Tod
The advice about Munich Liam & Pasing was invaluable Cowboy- once again am so pleased to be a member of the Fodorite family! All you have to do is ask.....even if the questions seem dumb at the time.
My heartfelt thanks to all of you,
Tod



