I need to choose between the following:

Hotel Aprile: Standard double for EUR120
Hotel Caravaggio: Double with view for EUR110
Hotel Boccaccioouble superion for EUR99

Any thoughts? Thank you so much!

topping - i need help!

I'm sorry that I'm not familar with any of these properties... I'd suggest locating near the Duomo or the Galleria degli Uffizi for location, location however.

mbriones-

If you type each hotel name + Florence up on the search box above, you will find some old threads about these hotels.
There were posts asking about both Hotels Caravaggio & Boccaccio, and it seems like very few people on this forum have stayed at either one. There were a few more posts about Aprile, but they dated back to 2001 & 02.
Have you tried looking up reviews on tripadvisor & venere.com?

good luck!

May I ask you where you got those rates. They seem better than any we've seen or have been quoted for these hotels. We are going to Florence in May and also liked the Aprile and boccaccio.

I contacted the hotels directly via email. I will be going in August, which for the most part is considered low-mid season. Good luck!