I'd appreciate your recommendations for a villa stay in St. John. We're 3 adults, looking for a 3 bedroom in the $1,800-2,500 price range (staying the 2 weeks after Thanksgiving).
TIA!

that price might be hard to find but you have a shot, , 2500 to 3000 is more likely but try caribbeanvilla.com they have st. john and tortola rentals. we used them last year and were very satisfied. (but we had to pay 2400 for a week) i looked and there are villas available during your time frame but i only took a quick look.

Check www.privatehomesvi.com, they have some very reasonably priced villas. I'm researching villas currently for our second trip to St John next summer and we'll likely be renting from them (I seriously considered them for our first visit but we chose a villa that was through another agency instead).

I second Jeanne's recommendation. See if Tree Tops is available. It is very nice and has three private bedrooms...

One more thought...if you are there two weeks, you could even consider staying at two different places...one each week.

I have a couple reasons for my rationale...you have a pretty low price range and this range tends to book the fastest, so finding one place for two straight weeks may be tough. St. John is small, but we have found that staying on different parts of the island, we tend to see and do different things, so if you found two different villas in different parts of the island, you will experience more things.

I know a lot of folks that have spilt time at different places and I don't think it would be too difficult of inconvenient.