Has anyone ever used a travel/villa booking company called Personal Choice Villas?

They are a UK based company, are you in the UK? If not, it may not be the best avenue with exchange rates.

Thanks for your reply, but they are out of New York.

They are based in UK, its no surprise they have an office in NY. Where are you looking for villas? I can tell you this, a company like that will cost you more money, and they'll be great villas but villas along those same lines can be gotten for much cheaper if you know the right resources. Let me know I may be able to help. Been renting worldwide for decades. I know most of the companies.

I used them for a wonderful Villa rental in Jamaica.
They rent Villas in the Caribbean, mainly in Jamaica, Barbados and St. Lucia

The Company I used for my Villa rental is based in New York City.
I used them for a wonderful Villa rental in Jamaica.
They rent Villas in the Caribbean, mainly in Jamaica, Barbados and St. Lucia