The last time we were in St. John was in 2009 and in August so I can't remember if we needed restaurant reservations for places in Cruz Bay. This time we're going in January when the island will be more crowded. Thoughts?

Whether or not you need dinner reservations varies from restaurant to restaurant and by day of week. It's always wise to call ahead and make reservations - after all it's just a phone call.

I would make reservations. You're going during the winter season. You can always cancel if your plans change, so no harm in a simple phone call or two, right?

I agree with roamsaround. Depends on where you go. I would make a reservation at the high end places or if you have a large party. The day before would probably be fine. I just got back. Ate at The Lime Inn, Rhumblines, High Tide, Da Livio and a new place called Virgin Fire. All were excellent meals. If you like thin crust pizza definitely try Da Livio's. Delicious. They have a wood burning stove on the patio. The old JJ's reopened right after I left and has been renovated. Getting great reviews so far. Apparently good breakfast fare, now called Cruz Bay Landing.

In the winter in the Caribbean, it is always a good idea to call ahead. In August, if the place is open, you are usually welcomed with open arms. In season, many of the good places are jammed and walk-ins may get turned away.

We were there last March. Had luck getting into every restaurant with no reservation except for Zozo's at Gallows Point. There you have to reserve a seat at the bar because the view is so great!

FYI - our absolutely favorite place was FATTY CRAB. Very different, fresh vibe, upscale but very eclectic food and actually reasonable prices.

Zozo's is a nice place to eat and a resv. only takes a call. It is very popular with the regular snow birds from the main land who spend winters in STT and take the ferry over to SJ. Hence the need for the call!

Zozo's is now at Caneel Bay. A new restaurant, Ocean 362, is in the old Gallow's Point location. You do need reservations for both.

Thanks eastender.wWill be happy to go to Caneel Bay next month!! always liked Zozo's.