I have already booked my hotel stay at the T&C Club for april of next year but am second guessing myself. I am wondering if we would really notice a big difference in staying here or at Coral Gardens oceanfront condo? It is for our 25th anniversary. What do you all think?

I wasn't impressed with Coral Garden's location and was glad I didn't say there. It gets very busy in front of and beside the condo complex with snorkellers, beachers. It also looks visibly older than the T&C club.

T&C Club and Coral Gardens are a stone's throw away from each other. I love T&C Club, the gorounds are gorgeous, on a fine stretch of beach, and they welcome you family. I've stay there before, and I will stay there again.

you've made an excellent choice. stick with it. for your anniversary dinner you might consider anacaona at the grace bay club. it's beautiful!
or possibly arrange a private dinner served on the beach...

I wasn't impressed with Coral Gardens either.

I agree, T&C Club would be my choice over Coral Gardens. Coral Gardens seemed more hectic when we were there. And, as stated, it's a short walk away. We had lunch there and used the outdoor PC for Internet access several times. It looks quite nice, but I think T&C is more romantic and elegant for an anniversary.

Magnolia (at Smith's Point?) is also a very nice place for a romantic dinner. Congratulations!