This what comes up when I search AA flights, using miles, from CA to Honolulu. Does anyone know anything about Compass Airlines?

They are a regional airline that’s been around since 2006. They operate flights for Delta Connection and American Eagle.

FYI - almost all American Eagle flights (and Delta Connection flights and the “short hop commuter arms” of the larger airlines) are operated by a local regional airline. In your case the plane itself will be painted in American Eagle livery even though it is “operated by” Compass. This is a standard practice in the industry.

Hmmm..don't think we want a local regional airline. Back to the drawing board.

Why? Compass is fine and other than the smaller plane you probably won’t notice the difference. Depending where you are flying from, you may not have a choice.

Why on earth not?

Every single time I fly international (which is a lot) my first leg will be on a regional carrier - often American Eagle/Compass/whatever to LAX or to PHX or whichever major airport my airline uses. You still get the miles, still can use the Lounge if eligible, etc etc.

These feeder services are usually so integrated into the big company's operations that they look and feel like one company. If you can find an international service from your airport then certainly consider it, but you may not have a choice.

NOT fond of smaller planes, as flying is not one of my favorite things.

Looks like Hawaiian will be the best choice, as there are direct flights from SMF to HNL.

FWIW, the planes Compass flies for AA aren’t that small. They look to only operate the E175 for AA, which is a very comfortable plane.

That being said, if price is equal, the nonstop would be preferred anyway.

Hawaiian Air is my all time favorite airline. If there's any way to fly them... fly them!

That's our plan, if we can find the hotel that's just right. So far one otherwise perfect one doesn't have lanais (the Prince), and the Waikiki Parc is sold out forever.