32 Best Restaurants in Rincón and the Porta del Sol, Puerto Rico

Background Illustration for Restaurants

If you like seafood, you're in the right place. Throughout northwestern Puerto Rico you'll find wonderful criollo (Puerto Rican creole) cuisine. Most local eateries serve deep-fried tapas, commonly called frituras (meaning "fritters"). Offering a break from fried food are dozens of foreign-owned eateries that serve everything from sushi and hamburgers to vegetarian and Thai cuisine. Farther south along the coast options are limited, so you may want to ask the chef to grill or sauté your fish. A trip to Puerto Rico is not complete without sampling Puerto Rico’s most iconic dish, mofongo relleno, made from fried, seasoned and mashed plantain or yuca stuffed with your choice of seafood or meat. Simply head to where locals from all over the island go for fresh seafood—Joyuda. When it comes to beverages, locals usually drink rum and coke or mix it with fresh-squeezed orange or grapefruit juice. You’ll also see people sipping on Medalla Light, Puerto Rico's most popular and affordable beer. All restaurants are no-smoking. Tips, normally 15%–20%, are usually not included in the bill, but it's always wise to double-check.

Estela

$$$ Fodor's choice

On weekends, patrons come from as far as San Juan to dine at this cozy restaurant. Operated by husband-and-wife team Juan and Nerylu, it's found a niche in Rincón offering dishes made using locally sourced ingredients—you may even see a fisherman pull up with a giant yellowfin tuna. The regularly changing menu by Chef Abel Mendoza might feature dishes such as queen-snapper sashimi with papaya and tiger's milk (the liquid used to cure ceviche), braised short ribs over root-vegetable mash, or duck à l'orange with roasted squash. You can't go wrong with any of the daily specials. The dining room can get loud, so ask to be seated outside on the terrace.

Rte. 115, Km 14, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–1795
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Farm-to-table dining
  • Good wine list
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun. and Mon. No lunch, Reservations required

The English Rose

$ Fodor's choice

Open for breakfast only, this quaint bed-and-breakfast has a spectacular view of the valley spilling into the sea. If terrace seating is not available, indoor dining is equally charming, with walls colorfully adorned by the work of local artisans. House specialties like eggs Benedict are served with homemade breads and sausages. The "BBC" is quite popular—a toasted croissant topped with organic chicken, cranberry sausage, poached egg, and hollandaise sauce—but we can't stop thinking about the "Portobello Road," made with roasted portobello mushroom, smoked Gouda, thick-cut black forest ham, and cherry tomato confit on a fresh-baked croissant. Enhancing the freshness of the dishes are the herbs grown on-site. You can now sip on a mimosa or homemade Bloody Mary while overlooking the lush mountain and ocean below. During high season, you might wait up to an hour for a table, so reservations are recommended.

101 West Kitchen & Bar

$$

This casual restaurant serving new American cuisine is a must when visiting Boquerón. Sit on the patio and indulge in tasty dishes like lobster mac 'n' cheese, pork sliders, and key lime pie.

Rte. 101, Km 5.7, Boquerón, 00623, Puerto Rico
787-649–4320
Known For
  • Lobster mac 'n' cheese
  • Good drinks from the bar
  • Sunday brunch
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. and Tues.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Annie's Place

$$

A dining room facing the ocean is a fitting place to try some of the southwest coast's best seafood. You can snack on empanadillas (fritters), then move on to red snapper with rice and beans or mofongo relleno. This place, in an unmistakable lime-color building on the main drag, has festive music and great views.

Rte. 3301, Km 3, Cabo Rojo, 00623, Puerto Rico
787-254–2553
Known For
  • Fresh red snapper
  • Waterfront dining with great ocean views
  • Empanadillas

Buena Vibra

$$
Located right on Route 308, this no-frills Puerto Rican restaurant has an inviting, relaxed vibe. Friendly staffers serve local specialties like stuffed avocado, churrasco, and mofongo.
Rte. 308, Km 7.1, Cabo Rojo, 00623, Puerto Rico
787-718–0024
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Stuffed avocado
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. and Tues.

Cafe 2 Go

$
For the best coffee in town, make your way to this tiny food cart off Route 413. Owner Aaron makes an awesome latte using local Puerto Rican coffee. Açaí bowls and made-to-order fruit smoothies are also on the menu.
Rte. 413, Km 0.5, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
Known For
  • Puerto Rican coffee
  • Açaí bowls
  • Made-to-order fruit smoothies
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed June–Oct.

Café 413

$$

This multicuisine dining locale is coffee shop, restaurant, and bar all in one. Conveniently located right on the town square, it's a great place for a latte, smoothie, wrap, or even a full breakfast or dinner. The staff are friendly, and they cater to families. Gluten-free and vegan items are served.

157 Calle Progreso, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
939-697–8188
Known For
  • Breakfast
  • Family-friendly dining
  • Gluten-free and vegan choices
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Wed.

CINCO

$$$

Although the menu at this family-friendly restaurant includes pizza and pasta dishes, it's a good place to dine on hearty Caribbean fare, including Puerto Rican specialties like mofongo, churrasco, and bistec encebollado. The wine list is short but well curated, and the cocktails are creative and affordable.

D'Rose Chocolate Factory

$

This truffle treasure hidden in a nondescript strip mall has a reputation for fantastic coffee. The aroma of chocolate entices passersby into the sweet shop with its pink candy-striped walls and chocolate-tone tables. Rotating glass towers display rich cakes and pastries, while endless rows of candy jars further tempt the palate. Chocolate-covered strawberries and gourmet truffles are all made in-house and are served by adorable grandmothers in their Little Miss Muffet–like uniforms topped with lace bonnets.

Rte. 107, Km 2.1, Aguadilla, 00603, Puerto Rico
787-891–0552
Known For
  • Excellent coffee
  • Large variety of chocolates
  • Baked goods

De Raiz

$$$

Chef Juan Camacho's newest venture brings him to the college town of Mayaguez. Here, he elevates the dining scene in town. The restaurant has small butcher shop. 

Downtown by José Carles

$$$
Former executive chef of the Royal Isabela resort, José Carles, is now the proprietor of this restaurant in his home town. His menu focuses on seafood, most of which he catches himself, and dishes might include fish crudo with passion fruit, grilled lobster, blackened shrimp, or octopus risotto. The wait may be long as Downtown is popular with locals, but the outdoor terrace with a full bar is a great place to relax until your table is ready.
9 Calle José de Diego, Boquerón, 00622, Puerto Rico
787-366–6166
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • Crudo specials
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. and Tues.

El Bohío

$$

Watch seagulls dive for their food while you dine on a covered deck extending out into the bay. The long list of seafood is prepared in a variety of ways: shrimp comes breaded, stewed, or skewered; conch is served as a salad or cooked in a butter-and-garlic sauce; and the lobster can be prepared just about any way you can imagine. This restaurant, on stilts above the water, is about the most charming setting in Joyuda.

Rte. 102, Km 13.9, Joyuda, 00623, Puerto Rico
787-851–2755
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Idyllic waterfront setting
  • Lobster prepared many ways
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Oct.

Flora

$$$

Farm to table is the focus at Flora. Upscale, well-thought-out dishes are presented in a casual setting. You'll find anything from cured local fish, duck confit, and locally foraged chanterelles on the rotating menu. 

Carr 110, Aguadilla, 00609, Puerto Rico
Known For
  • Creative, rotating menu
  • Vegetarian friendly
  • Farm to table

Jack's Shack

$
This popular food cart across from Pool's Beach serves healthy breakfasts and lunches featuring seasonal ingredients and the catch of the day. The fish tacos are popular, though the menu also has veggie burgers and quinoa salads. Tasty fresh pressed juices are available for your pre- or post-surf session.
Rte. 413 Ramal, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
939-274–8066
Known For
  • Fish tacos
  • Breakfast burritos
  • Fresh-pressed juices
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: No dinner

La Cambija

$

You'll find some of the freshest seafood in town at this casual roadside restaurant. Order an assortment of grilled fish skewers, choosing from tuna, mahimahi, grouper, wahoo, rainbow runner, and more. The lobster is excellent, and the empanadas are great, too. Happy hour lasts all day—no wonder it's always packed.

Calle Cambija, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–1118
Known For
  • Grilled fish skewers
  • House-made empanadas
  • Happy-hour drink prices all day

La Copa Llena at the Black Eagle

$$

Join patrons from across the island for spectacular sunsets at this restaurant right on the beach. Whether you choose one of the small plates or an entrée, fresh seafood is always your best bet. Start with the roasted beet salad or the fried cauliflower, then move on to the steamed mussels in a sambucca cream sauce or the grilled fish of the day with coconut green curry sauce. The large wooden deck, illuminated by strings of lights, is a wonderful spot to sit back, relax, and enjoy the views with cocktail in hand. The doors open at 5 pm, but the days of operation vary by season, so verify hours prior to visiting.

Black Eagle Rd., Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–0896
Known For
  • Fresh seafood
  • Sunset drinks
  • Great outdoor deck
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun., Mon., Sept., and Oct. No lunch.

La Sirena Sushi & Tiki Bar

$$

One of only a few sushi restaurants on the west coast, the former Pool Bar Sushi attracts visitors from as far away as San Juan. The menu rivals that of any high-end Japanese restaurant, with mango tuna rolls, eel maki, shumai, and wakame seaweed salads. A house favorite is the Starving Surfer Roll: crunchy shrimp and avocado topped with spicy tuna. Their new location is in town is just a block from the main plaza.

15 Calle Comercio, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–2583
Known For
  • Sushi rolls
  • Fish tacos for lunch
  • Movie night

Mangia Mi

$$
Chef Rebecca White of Food Network's Cooks vs. Cons whips up Italian creations at her newest venture in Rincón. The open kitchen allows you to see the staff meticulously preparing each dish amid strands of hanging, freshly made pasta. The menu focuses primarily on grilled artisanal pizzas and pastas (half and full portions). Pair whatever you get with one of the reasonably priced bottles of wine. Happy hour is from 4 to 6 pm.

Mimosa Brunch Farm to Table

$$

Breakfast and brunch are served all day at this popular restaurant in Aguada. Perfectly cooked eggs Benedict and creative dishes like bacalaito pancakes can be found on the menu. There are plenty of vegetarian and gluten free options and many mimosa flavors to choose from. Many ingredients come from neighboring farms. 

Mister Harry

$$

Locals come from as far as San Juan to get a taste of the Thai dishes at Mister Harry. The short yet tasty menu features a selection of curries. 

Gate 5 Plaza, Aguadilla, 00603, Puerto Rico
Known For
  • Curries
  • Thai cuisine
  • Local favorite
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon.--Thurs.

Ola Lola's Tiki Bar

$

The owners have maximized their residence, which boasts "the friendliest wave on the island," by converting the garage into overflow seating for this garden bistro. With fairy lights, beach chairs, and Latin music, the no-frills setting complements the simple menu of burgers, sandwiches, and signature dips. Creative creations include chipotle chicken nachos, beer-battered fish tacos, the peanut butter burger (just try it!), and cauliflower buffalo bites. Try the "Tropical Dreamsicle," the restaurant's version of a piña colada. For an interesting keepsake, buy one of the souvenir T-shirts from each of the island's top surf spots. Ola Lola's is cash only.

Rte. 4466, Km 2.1, Isabela, 00622, Puerto Rico
787-872–1230
Known For
  • Peanut-butter burgers (you gotta try one)
  • "Tropical Dreamsicle" piña coladas
  • Cash only

Parrilleria Vacas Gauchas

$$$
Excellent cuts of meat—from filet mignon and rib eye to pork loin—are the draws here. Splurgeworthy dry-aged porterhouse and kurobuta pork are also likely to be on the menu. The service is excellent.
Rte. 115, Km 11.8, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-529–1200
Known For
  • Family-friendly restaurant
  • Great meats
  • Fantastic service
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon.

Reina Mora

$$$$

Located on the Rincón–Aguada border, this supper club run by a husband-and-wife team has a multicourse menu that changes weekly and highlights locally sourced and grown food (add a bag of produce from area farms to take home). Vegan and vegetarian options are available upon request, and it's BYOB. Dinners are by reservation only and they sell out quickly. Note, too, that payment is made at the time of booking.

Restaurant at La Casa

$$$

Many things stand out at this picturesque resort restaurant: the emerald-green golf course in the foreground, the majestic cliffs on the coast, and the roaring ocean in the background. A fair amount of the fruits and vegetables used in the dishes here are grown at Royal Isabela's River Farm and Gatehouse Garden; all the fish is caught offshore.

396 Av. Noel Estrada, Isabela, 00662, Puerto Rico
787-609–5888
Known For
  • Freshest seafood
  • Caribbean lobster specials
  • Farm-to-table approach

Ricomini Bakery

$

Open daily 5 am–midnight, this popular bakery is a good spot to try one of the city's trademark delicacies: the brazo gitano (gypsy arm), a gigantic jelly roll filled with anything from guava to sweet cheese. There are also tasty pastries like flan, tres leches cake, mallorcas, and cheesecake, as well as freshly baked bread and a selection of sandwiches.

101 Calle Méndez Vigo, Mayagüez, 00680, Puerto Rico
787-832–0565
Known For
  • Brazo gitano jelly rolls
  • Fido's sangria
  • Sandwiches for lunch
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: No dinner

Sana Farm to Table

$

This charming restaurant specializes in vegan, vegetarian, and pescatarian dishes. The summer rolls are made with veggies from local farms, and the fish in the poké bowl features the catch of the day. The signature juices, designed to boost your immunity, are the perfect post-surfing treat.

PR-413, Km 4.1, Rincón, Puerto Rico
787-823–7621
Known For
  • Green juices
  • Vegetarian food
  • Healthy eats
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: No dinner

Shipwreck Bar & Grill

$$$

This pirate-themed restaurant has a laid-back vibe and a friendly staff who are always ready with a smile or a joke. Don't be surprised to see local fishermen making their way to the kitchen with their still-flapping catch. Entrées include juicy steaks, grilled mahimahi, homemade pastas, and stuffed mofongo. Although portions are large, lighter options are available, including fish tacos, a selection of wraps, and seared ahi tuna served on a pyramid of mixed greens. Don't miss happy hour (daily 3–7).

Black Eagle Rd., Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–0578
Known For
  • Fresh seafood and steaks
  • Kid-friendly dining environment
  • Large portions
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: No lunch weekdays

Tamboo

$$

The best thing about this bar and grill is its beachfront location. The open-air venue serves a mean mojito, and the deck is a great place to watch novice surfers wipe out on the beach. The kitchen prepares a wide range of unique items, from fresh-fish sandwiches to baby back ribs brushed with guava sauce. On weekends, you can enjoy live music.

Rte. 413, Km 4.4, Rincón, 00677, Puerto Rico
787-823–8550
Known For
  • Guava barbecue ribs
  • Fish sandwiches
  • Drinks on the deck
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sept.

The Coffee Spot

$
You'll love the chill vibe at this café, where you can sip on a latte, use Wi-Fi, and enjoy a creative sandwich. Most dishes and drinks are named after famous composers and classical pieces, and sometimes there's live piano music.
Rte. 110, Km 4.6, Aguadilla, 00603, Puerto Rico
787-996–7340
Known For
  • Great coffee
  • Good spot for breakfast
  • Friendly service
Restaurant Details
Rate Includes: No dinner

The Eclipse

$$$

Beautiful beachfront dining, farm-to-table ingredients, and fantastic service are worth the drive from San Juan. The setting is rustic yet elegant, and the view is unbeatable. Sweet and savory brunch selections range from coconut brioche French toast with caramelized bananas and nuts to pizza frittatas. Lunch brings delicious, classic, Neapolitan pizzas baked in a handmade brick oven. The catch-of-the-day ceviche—caught in Isabela—is perfectly marinated, and lobster is usually on the dinner menu.