Deciding between these hotels........any opinions?

My daughter and son-in-law stayed at the W last year and had a wonderful time. I think they would stay there again.

My wife and I stayed at the Millenium Broadway several weeks ago for a weekend visit. We thought it was nice. Booked it on Priceline for $110/night, so that made it even better! From what I have read about NYC hotel rooms, it seemed to be a decent size room. The staff that we encountered was friendly. We would stay there again. Great location for seeing the sights at either of these hotels, so whatever your choice I think you'll be okay.

We have stayed in W three times and Millenium once,and take W over Millenium any time.

Hey we were shoved and blocked by secret service guys the other day pushing us out of the way for the Dalai Lama arriving at his hotel -- The Millenium. If it's good enough for him, how bad could it be? I wonder if he booked on Priceline?

I stayed at the Millenium for $93 per night from Priceline. The rooms were very plain but spacious. My other NYC experiences have been in boutique hotels with no elbow room! I preferred the space and the nice big windows......