vjpblovesitaly

“'nice try, but not quite what we're looking for' response."

I would tell them to look themselves if they're so darn particular.

The 20s somethings shouldn’t have a say in the matter. Have they ever treated anyone to a meal?

NeoPatrick

Whenever someone says "not quite what I'm looking for" then I say "what EXACTLY are you looking for?" Obviously if they think it isn't quite it, then they must have a very exact idea of what it is they are looking for. That is such a meaningless statement -- "not quite what we're looking for".

lisettemac

UES: Brasserie Julien is a good idea. What about Atlantic Grill? Or Sarabeth's at the Whitney?

janie

Thanks for the additional ideas.

Planning a get together for a large group is not my idea of fun, but I said I'd help, so...
And yes, compromises will be made by all! The "nice try, but not quite what we're looking for" was definitely a paraphrase of a more thankful sounding response. The price range was a little limiting at first, and then the timing and locations were really narrowed down a little more, so I think there will be a winner in this group.

poodle13905

We chanced upon an amazing 3-course price fixe lunch in SoHo at Peep. Great Thai food and very cool ambience.

http://peepsoho.net/

tower

Wishing you luck and thick skin, Janie. If all else fails with the veggie folks, send them out to graze in Central Park.

Stu T.