I am deciding between the Canfield House or the Spiced Pear for a romantic dining experience on New Year's eve in NewPort, Rhode island- Any comments on either one? thanks.

Spiced Pear....not even close.

Spiced Pear is much better.
Also Castle Hill Inn

Castle Hill Inn. If you stay thru midnight you can catch the fireworks from their lawn.

In case you're not thoroughly convinced: Spiced Pear,first choice. Castle Hill, second choice. Both have spectacular views, both offer fantastic dining experiences but in my opinion, however, Spiced Pear is a bit more au courant.

My husband and I stopped into the Canfield House, as we've heard that in it's heyday (15 years ago?) it was quite a place....today think: bloated, aged, and very outdated-preppy. Dated decor. Boring, uninspired menu.

Foods a bit more interesting and more costly at the Spiced pear but the fireworks at Castle Hill will be outstanding - I know you didn't ask.
The Black pearl would also offer an exc. meal and put you in a nice walk around area around the harbor.

I agree with others in that the Canfield house can be a bit stodgy. Great chartobrau (destroyed spelling - sorry)is excellent, though.
Enjoy!