Which resort would you reccomend for a family traveling with a one year old baby? We stayed at the FS Maui last year and loved it, but this year are considering trying something different (BI or Punta Mita). However, both of these resorts are more expensive than Maui, and we are just wondering it they are worth the extra money.

Have you also considered the 4S property on Nevis? I have heard wonderful things about it! Also heard that it is less humid than most of the Caribbean islands during the summertime so you can get a good deal during the summer months (on the 4S website) and still enjoy the weather.

All of these resorts will be wonderful. I would choose where you want to go (Nevis, Hawaii, or Mexico) and then stay at that property. We went to the 4S Maui last Christmas with our family so I know what you mean about having a great time! Just to let you know for future visits if you expand your family, the 4S on the Big Island only allows 3 people in a standard room. Our family of four would have to be in a suite which is $900 for a golf course view! I have heard that this property is amazing though! Enjoy where ever you go!