I'm planning a 15th wedding anniversary dinner for my wife and I during our upcoming visit to Charleston, and wanted some Fodorite recommendations for Peninsula Grill vs. Charleston Grill. Thanks.

What a great dilema! You cannot make a wrong choice with either one!

I was just at both last week for my anniversary. We stayed at Charleston Place. For dinner, we liked the Peninsula Grill much better. Their menu, for us, had much more to choose from. Take a look at their menu's on-line. If you go to Peninsula, try the banana pudding for dessert. It is totally different from any banana pudding you might have had!
Have a great time,
Aimee

Wow! I had the exact same question...only ours is just our 9th anniversary. I had pretty much decided on the Peninsula Grill. Does anyone (yoohoo....GoTravel?) know how far out one should make reservations? We will be there at the end of this month.

Call now for a table. I called a month before for 7:30 and they only had 7:00 and 8:30.

Aimee, were you satisfied with Charleston Place? We're staying there as well, and it has been a number of years since I've stayed there.