What exactly encompasses Bavaria?
#2

Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 12,332
Likes: 0
Bavaria is one of the states of Germany - here the link to the wikipedia site
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bavaria
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bavaria
#3
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 9,016
Likes: 0
The whole world, except for Prussia, which is defined anywhere that isn't Bavaria.
How about a map

http://www.eurotourism.com/DE/img/bayern.gif
How about a map

http://www.eurotourism.com/DE/img/bayern.gif
#5

Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 12,332
Likes: 0
California. Is that part of the US or Mexico?
Tirol. Part of Austria or Italy?
The answer in both cases is yes - part of both. There are lots of examples where modern day political boundaries cutting ethnic, cultural, or formerly larger regions in two.
Unless you know all the history of a particular region, including boundaries that shift with wars, treaties and purchases it's not easy to know everything.
The fact that southern Germany and much of Austria share a similar language and many cultural traits makes connie's an understandable question.
Tirol. Part of Austria or Italy?
The answer in both cases is yes - part of both. There are lots of examples where modern day political boundaries cutting ethnic, cultural, or formerly larger regions in two.
Unless you know all the history of a particular region, including boundaries that shift with wars, treaties and purchases it's not easy to know everything.
The fact that southern Germany and much of Austria share a similar language and many cultural traits makes connie's an understandable question.
Trending Topics
#8
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,886
Likes: 0
Bavaria has nothing to do with Austria.
It is a large section of southestern Germany which until WWI was a separate country from Germany (thus all the recent Mad King Ludwig Castles from the 1860's). Bavaria had a King until 1918 when it was merged with the rest of Germany under the new Republic.
It is a large section of southestern Germany which until WWI was a separate country from Germany (thus all the recent Mad King Ludwig Castles from the 1860's). Bavaria had a King until 1918 when it was merged with the rest of Germany under the new Republic.
#10
Original Poster
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 1,960
Likes: 0
The reason I thought it might be a larger area than just part of Germany was because I recently read someone's question about going to Bavaria and she was planning to go to Germany, Austria and the BO of Switzerland.
Thanks to those of you who were helpful. I don't quite get why some felt the need to TRY to be funny or condescending.
Thanks to those of you who were helpful. I don't quite get why some felt the need to TRY to be funny or condescending.
#15
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,886
Likes: 0
Sorry -
In 1871 von Bismarck "unifid" Germany as an Empire - still made up of many separate constituent States - under the Prussian Kaiser (caesar). However, Bavaria had a separate King (Ludwig #?) until 1918 - when the revolution after the fall of Germany in WWI restructured the entire country.
Austria had - for hundreds of years - been the center of the Austro-Hungarian Empire ruled by the Hapsburgs.
And Switzerland - as a confederation of "nations" has also existed as a separete country for hundreds of years.
The person who referred to Bavaria, Austria and Switzerland was just talking about going to several diffrent places on vacation.
As for the "Reich" starting in Bavaria - well I'm not surprised at anything that could come out of those beerhalls. But since it lasted only about 20 years and no longer exists - it is really immaterial.
In 1871 von Bismarck "unifid" Germany as an Empire - still made up of many separate constituent States - under the Prussian Kaiser (caesar). However, Bavaria had a separate King (Ludwig #?) until 1918 - when the revolution after the fall of Germany in WWI restructured the entire country.
Austria had - for hundreds of years - been the center of the Austro-Hungarian Empire ruled by the Hapsburgs.
And Switzerland - as a confederation of "nations" has also existed as a separete country for hundreds of years.
The person who referred to Bavaria, Austria and Switzerland was just talking about going to several diffrent places on vacation.
As for the "Reich" starting in Bavaria - well I'm not surprised at anything that could come out of those beerhalls. But since it lasted only about 20 years and no longer exists - it is really immaterial.
#17
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 390
Likes: 0
...as did Württemberg. Baden, Hessen and others were grand duchies, Braunschweig, Anhalt etc. duchies, serveral other states were principalities; all with their courts, orders, pageantry and without any notable sovereignty regarding foreign policy. There were a few free hanseatic cities bringing some republican relief into the german Empire.
Hi Ingo, we're back in the Champions' league, got my tickets today
Phil.
Hi Ingo, we're back in the Champions' league, got my tickets today

Phil.
#18
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 817
Likes: 0
Well, this is very informative to me, as I've been researching my family tree (which I thought was nearly 75 % Irish, LOL) and have traced many ancestors back to Baden-Wurttemberg, Hesse, and little towns such as Lobenrot and Strumpfelbach. Who knew? And I didn't realize that they didn't consider themselves "German" at the time. I'm doing this in the hopes of planning a trip that will encompass visits to some of these places. Thanks for the education.
#20
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 380
Likes: 0
Your ancestors might have considered themselves Germans. It's just that there was no country called "Germany" until the late 19th century (the closest would have been the very early Holy Roman Empire, after the "France"/"Germany" divide and before the emperors lost all illusions of actually ruling the land).
In the same way, there was no country called "Italy" until roughly the same period. But there still were many Italians.
In the same way, there was no country called "Italy" until roughly the same period. But there still were many Italians.

