i read a terrible review regarding the hotel saint germain des pres. i know there are other hotels of this name the one i am interested in is on Rue bonaparte has anyone stayed there latel and had good results. i stayed in 2004 and loved it but would like update.

1. where did you see the terrible review..?
2. have you checked on TripAdvisor.com ?
3. how about Venere.com (if the hotel is on that site, they do have comments)

on this site Ira is the expert on the hôtel bonaparte. he will see this post and respond to your question. your

ttt

tying your two threads together:
http://www.fodors.com/forums/threads...p;tid=34750681

ttt

I stayed for 3 nights in October 2004 in one of the rooms on the top florr (I should say the top floor reached by elevator-not the topmost reached by a flight of stairs). The room was pretty large with double dormer windows, bed comfortable and really nice bathroom. The room, however was very dark. It was nice for a short stay but would have gone mad if staying any longer than a weekend. The staff was friendly. My husband believes that the croissants he had there for breakfast are the best he's ever tasted!