We have the wonderful opportunity of staying at either of these two hotels for two nights in October. They are both very expensive, but because we are traveling off season, and I guess, because of the economy, they are both offering very good deals. Anyone stayed at either, or both who can guide me??? thanks

We loved Le Sirenuse - beautiful rooms with views over the water. Great breakfast - cappucino, breads, cheeses, salame, fruits - on the patio also overlooking the water. It was a luxurious experience. And valet parking if you have a car!

I don't know the hotels, but Le Sirenuse is in Positano, which is quite touristy at any time of the year, and Hotel Caruso is in Ravello, which is more laid-back but in the hills above Amalfi and more difficult to get around from.

As always, pick the location not the hotel. Both are great--Ravello is isolated--your call.

Thanks for the replies. Following Bob's advice we will be staying at Hotel Caruso in Ravello. It looks beautiful and a little less touristy than Positano.

We had lunch at the Caruso many years ago... on a terrace overlooking a splendid view. The hotel itself has been renovated extensively since then... I'm green with envy -

PS. I wonder if they still have the chocolate lemon souffle on the menu ??