Again a deadly shark attack - Fish Hoek
#1
Original Poster
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 4,215
Likes: 0
Again a deadly shark attack - Fish Hoek
Again a human fell prey to a great white at Fish Hoek.
http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_i...3538856631D526
http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_i...3538856631D526
#4
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
Millions of people swim in South African waters every year, many going in several times a day, and many going in many times a year. I wonder what the % increase has been over the years.
And there are many, many sharks out there (and not only the marine variety).
But WOW! Suddenly there's this huge increase in shark attacks. Up to 3 attacks per year. OMW, we have to careful and avoid the ocean completely.
Get Real!
This article smacks of sensationalism!
Don't get me wrong! I don't support cage diving. If you want to dive sharks, have the courage to free-dive them! It takes no brains and no guts to sit in a cage! But as long as people will pay for this activity there will be a market.
I don't support cage diving. But I also don't support nonsense!
And there are many, many sharks out there (and not only the marine variety).
But WOW! Suddenly there's this huge increase in shark attacks. Up to 3 attacks per year. OMW, we have to careful and avoid the ocean completely.
Get Real!
This article smacks of sensationalism!
Don't get me wrong! I don't support cage diving. If you want to dive sharks, have the courage to free-dive them! It takes no brains and no guts to sit in a cage! But as long as people will pay for this activity there will be a market.
I don't support cage diving. But I also don't support nonsense!
#5
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 1,087
Likes: 0
What a comment:
"Don't get me wrong! I don't support cage diving. If you want to dive sharks, have the courage to free-dive them! It takes no brains and no guts to sit in a cage! But as long as people will pay for this activity there will be a market."
By implication it takes brains and guts to free dive with sharks... me thinks anyone who willingly free dives with great whites is lacking in grey matter and as for guts, well perhaps plain stupid.
I believe that there has been a pretty stiff southerly wind churning the ocean up and disorientating newly fledged seal pups from Seal Island, pushing them closer to shore and bringing a following of predatory sharks. I do not for a moment believe that this attack has any relationship with cage diving..simply a random and very sad event.
"Don't get me wrong! I don't support cage diving. If you want to dive sharks, have the courage to free-dive them! It takes no brains and no guts to sit in a cage! But as long as people will pay for this activity there will be a market."
By implication it takes brains and guts to free dive with sharks... me thinks anyone who willingly free dives with great whites is lacking in grey matter and as for guts, well perhaps plain stupid.
I believe that there has been a pretty stiff southerly wind churning the ocean up and disorientating newly fledged seal pups from Seal Island, pushing them closer to shore and bringing a following of predatory sharks. I do not for a moment believe that this attack has any relationship with cage diving..simply a random and very sad event.
#6
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,525
Likes: 0
As someone who has been to this area many times,it breaks my heart to hear about another shark attack. When are you "tourists" going to realize that going cage diving and throwing out the bloody bait interferes with nature? There is absolutely no reason to have this tourist activity when there are soooooo many other things to do and see in this area. the Western Cape is gorgeous;the people friendly and welcoming;the food is yummy and the sights are unbelievable.
#7
Original Poster
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 4,215
Likes: 0
BK and dutyfree
I totally agree with you and a lot of scientists/conservationists that baiting the sharks for the cage dives has a lot to do with these incidents.
It's not only said in SA but also in South Australia.
mkhonzo
Here you can get some information (sorry it's in German) on how harmless sharks are (incl. great white, tiger etc).
http://www.wirodive.de/sharkschool.htm
I think it's essential for divers and swimmers alike to realise that they all join "their habitat" and if something happens it's just by accident (humans are not on any shark's menu!) or human stupidity (or if you like lack of knowledge) involved.
Takes a huge effort to get rid of the images we all have got by watching the movie - and therefore have totally wrong perceptions of sharks.
SV
I totally agree with you and a lot of scientists/conservationists that baiting the sharks for the cage dives has a lot to do with these incidents.
It's not only said in SA but also in South Australia.
mkhonzo
Here you can get some information (sorry it's in German) on how harmless sharks are (incl. great white, tiger etc).
http://www.wirodive.de/sharkschool.htm
I think it's essential for divers and swimmers alike to realise that they all join "their habitat" and if something happens it's just by accident (humans are not on any shark's menu!) or human stupidity (or if you like lack of knowledge) involved.
Takes a huge effort to get rid of the images we all have got by watching the movie - and therefore have totally wrong perceptions of sharks.
SV
Trending Topics
#8
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
LOL mkhonzo,
The implication is wrong; the converse is not necessarily true. (I think that's something I learnt in maths, but I was thrown out of virtually every class - LOL).
At least if we have folk free diving with great whites, we might improve the universal IQ by default (and after reading the first article SV mentioned, and reading some of the comments, I've concluded that such an improvement is long overdue - LOL).
The implication is wrong; the converse is not necessarily true. (I think that's something I learnt in maths, but I was thrown out of virtually every class - LOL).
At least if we have folk free diving with great whites, we might improve the universal IQ by default (and after reading the first article SV mentioned, and reading some of the comments, I've concluded that such an improvement is long overdue - LOL).




here it is


