Cruises Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

S Carib. Cruise, Carnival or RC? Thomas/ Kitts, vs St John/Croix?

Jump to last reply

Sorry for long post in advance.....My boyfriend and I (32yo and 35yo, professionals, childless, from Columbus Ohio), & possibly 2-3 other couples have decided to do a last minute trip to somewhere warm and with beaches! We are thinking a southern caribbean cruise bc it has been on my list of islands I want to go. We are decently traveled....US (California, Colorado, Hawai, Vegas, Florida) London, Greek Islands, Italy, Estonia, Ireland, Mexico (several times staying a nice AI's in Cancun, Playa del carmen and Rivera maya) and Caribbean(Jamacia, St Maarten, Aruba, Bahamas, Florida Keys/Miami). We have to go on this trip I August because Dan has law school to finish and won't have another vacation until late next winter, otherwise, we'd do this cruise in the fall or NOv/Dec. We understand it will be hot...hope weather will be rain free and sunny?!
SOOOOO, I want to do a southern caribbean cruise mainly bc of the nice islands to see. Also, the only cruise I have done for comparison is NCL Pride of hawaii 5 yrs ago and like it. Since its August, there are only 2 cruises available...1) Carnival Victory and Royal Caribbean Serenade of the Seas. I hear that Carnival is the "fun ship" is that mean it is too geared for children and not for us? The ship is a few years older than RC. Royal Caribbean is a few hundred more expensive, a bit smaller (90, 000 tons) and a few yrs younger? Worth it? And lastly These bothe have the exact same port stops with the exception of Carnival goes to St Thomas and St Kitts while RC goes to St John and St Croix? Don't know much about those islands.
So you know our priorities:
As far as on the boat: food, cleanliness and quick embarking of the boat, gym quality are on the top of the list.
As far as ports: nice beaches, scenic islands and activities-we will either chill at a beach or do fun-activity excursions .

Can you make suggestions please!!!!! thanks in advance!!!!
Sweetness

18 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement: Writers Needed for Morocco Guidebook
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Apr 11, 14 at 05:51 PM
View all Cruises activity »
  1. 1 carnival curise customer care are not customer care at all!!!!!
  2. 2 decisions decisions ... advise please
  3. 3 Trip Report Celebrity Century Disaster Cruise
  4. 4 Trip Report An Epic Adventure
  5. 5 Trip Report Trip Report Windstar Panama Passage March 23 Sailing
  6. 6 Oceania-Marina-Scandinavian Treasures Cruise
  7. 7 Need some help finding the right cabin
  8. 8 Car Rental Marseille at Cruise Port
  9. 9 "Formal" Dinners on Coral Princess
  10. 10 queen mary question
  11. 11 Cruise themed music video filmed in the Bahamas
  12. 12 Trip Report Back from Epic cruise
  13. 13 Vantage River Cruises vs. Viking River Cruises
  14. 14 Cozumel excursions
  15. 15 Alaska Cruise with 3 children 4, 8 & 10
  16. 16 Trip Report Budget cruising in style: (5-day Carribean Cruise with Carnival)
  17. 17 Golf Cruise Hawaii?
  18. 18 Tips for Royal Caribbean trip
  19. 19 Anyone had problems with Affordable Tours?
  20. 20 Transatlantic/Repositioning Cruise in April
  21. 21 Trip Report A Disappointing Conquest
  22. 22 Japan cruise. Any feedback on these ports
  23. 23 Windstar for a first cruise?
  24. 24 Wind on board
  25. 25 Is the food quality generally the same on different ships in the same line?
View next 25 » Back to the top