3 Best Hotels in New York City, New York

Background Illustration for Hotels

There are more hotel rooms than ever in New York City, as exciting new properties continue to open their doors not only in Manhattan but in Brooklyn and the outer boroughs as well. But does that mean that New York is cheap? Well, we wouldn’t say cheap, but you can still find some deals, especially if you’re not set on a specific property or neighborhood, and if you don’t mind a few extra minutes of commuting time.

Hotels continue to slash rates based on market sensitivity—especially if you and all of those other Internet-savvy shoppers are willing to wait until the last minute. That said, if you want to stay in a specific place and the rate seems reasonable, book it—it's just as likely to go up, especially during peak seasons (spring and fall).

How to choose? The first thing to consider is location. Many New York City visitors insist on staying in the hectic Midtown area—and options are improving there—but other neighborhoods are often just as convenient. Less touristy areas, such as Gramercy, the Lower East Side, the Upper West Side—even Brooklyn—provide a more realistic sense of New York life, too.

Also consider timing: the least expensive months to book rooms in the city are January and February. If you're flexible on dates, ask the reservationist if there's a cheaper time to stay during your preferred traveling month—that way you can avoid peak dates, like Fashion Week and the New York City Marathon. Be sure to ask about possible weekend packages that could include a third night free. (The Financial District in particular can be a discount gold mine on weekends.)

Another source of bargains? Chain hotels. Many have moved into the city and charge reasonable room rates. In addition to favorites like the Sheraton, Hilton, and Hyatt brands, there are Best Westerns, Days Inns, and Comfort Inns. These rates aren't as low as you find outside Manhattan, but they're certainly getting closer.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

$$$$ | 60 Furman St., NY, 11201, USA Fodor's Choice

A sustainable ethos drives this hip, beautifully designed outpost of the 1 Hotels brand, as evidenced by a 20-foot plant wall punctuating the Brooklyn-inspired lobby, and filtered water bottle-filling stations in many guest rooms. The Neighbors café serves up breakfast and light fare until 5 pm, while upscale restaurant The Osprey serves finer fare, including oysters, pastas, and braised lamb. Cocktails with a view of the Manhattan skyline are mixed at rooftop Harriet's, which occasionally hosts live jazz or pool parties.

Pros

  • Fine dining at on-site restaurant, The Osprey
  • Stellar views of the Brooklyn Bridge
  • Rooftop pool and bar

Cons

  • East-facing rooms overlook busy thoroughfare
  • Pool closed in winter
  • Uneven service
60 Furman St., NY, 11201, USA
347-696–2500
Hotel Details
195 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

The Hoxton, Williamsburg

$$ | 97 Wythe Ave., Brooklyn, NY, 11249, USA

This trendy hotel truly exemplifies mid-century modern design with its decor and furniture, from its rooms to the spacious, yet cozy lobby—a welcoming place for a cocktail, or to just to work on your laptop. It's also home to acclaimed eateries K'Far and Laser Wolf, which grace the ground floor and rooftop.

Pros

  • Room views of the Manhattan skyline
  • Design-forward meeting spaces
  • Indoor/outdoor terrace bar, Jaffa

Cons

  • Rooms can be small
  • No fitness center or spa
  • Rooms without skyline view not exciting
97 Wythe Ave., Brooklyn, NY, 11249, USA
718-215–7100
Hotel Details
175 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Opera House Hotel

$ | 436 E. 149th St., Bronx, NY, 10455, USA

This historic, century-old building that was once the stage of the Marx Brothers and Harry Houdini in the early 20th century, has found new life as a beautifully renovated hotel that captures the essence of its former glory. Originally designed by New York architect George Keister, who completed the building in 1913—the same year he also did the famed Apollo Theatre in Harlem—this present-day hotel is a great value for exploration of the Bronx, with straightforward subway access into Manhattan.

Pros

  • On-site fitness center
  • 24/7 coffee station
  • Free Wi-Fi

Cons

  • Can be fully booked during Yankee home games
  • On a street that's often littered
  • Not in a trendy area
436 E. 149th St., Bronx, NY, 10455, USA
718-407–2800
Hotel Details
78 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video