Top Picks For You
New York City Travel Guide

Thinking About Moving Back to New York? Here Are 15 Reasons I Hated Living There

Unless you enjoy trash and being ripped off, then by all means, move on over.

The Big Apple sure is a magical place to vacation–museums straight out of the movies, dazzling Broadway shows starring what’s-her-name-again? from that-one-pop-band, and glittering Christmas lights on Fifth Avenue. It’s no wonder millions fall in love with it at first sight, myself included.

But like a holiday fling, things turned sour the moment I signed along that dotted line and committed to a full year living in Brooklyn and working in Manhattan. Now, I could list all the things I loved about our whirlwind relationship…but you’ve heard them all before (re: a certain J-Lo-led romantic comedy). Let’s be real. New York is also a stinking pile of crap, blown into a fan-like clockwork day in, day out. When crap hits the fan, divorce is imminent. For those flirting with the idea of moving back, stop immediately. Don’t let Jenny from the block seduce you (oh lord, give us strength!), not post-pandemic, not ever. Here’s a friendly reminder of what drove me insane.

1 OF 15

The Weather Is Harsh

Don’t bother packing for four seasons because you will only experience two, and they’re so extreme that fashion is the least of your worries. In winter, expect snow blizzards, brown slosh, and rain puddles the size of a koi pond. In summer, expect your day to be an extended sauna session interspersed with cryotherapy whenever you enter a bus or a branch of Target.

Spring and fall last approximately two weeks each, so that Con-Ed energy bill might actually be affordable one month of the entire year. If not, then perhaps a two-day power outage will do the trick.

2 OF 15

For the Price of a Baby, You Get to Live in a Freight Container

At around $3,500 per month ($42,000 per year, or the same cost of private adoption in the U.S.) you are granted the honor of a 450-square foot, one-bedroom apartment in Manhattan. The perks? Free workouts (it’s six flights of stairs to reach your apartment—there’s no elevator), more free workouts (laundry is in the basement), and, wait for it…even more free workouts (collecting your Amazon Prime orders before they are stolen from the lobby—there’s no doorman either). Who needs Equinox, eh?

3 OF 15

Your Friends Will Never Be F.R.I.E.N.D.S

Everybody is so super busy and important that you will never enjoy quality time in a group of six, let alone be dubbed the “Rachel” of the gang (sigh). Instead, your colleagues, acquaintances, neighbors, and people from will hate you or each other for no reason at all, unless you have a job with access to complimentary Book of Mormon tickets. Social distancing isn’t a protocol here, it’s a lifestyle.

4 OF 15

Everyone Is a Workaholic

“If you can make it here, you can make it anywhere.” Well, they got that right, because nowhere else in the world are so many people still busy past 9 p.m. Six months in, you’ll have adjusted to midnight Chipotle, increased volumes of vodka and Red Bull mixed into your coffee, and all 10 days of your annual leave days spent at a Catskills “spa,” more commonly known as rehab.

5 OF 15

The MTA Is a Disgrace

For those who think being the self-proclaimed “capital of the world” equates to advanced public transit systems, you’re awfully wrong. Rush hour trains run at 10 minutes or longer (don’t trust those busted digital signs) intervals and are maybe wiped down with a rag once in a blue moon (when the MTA proudly announces, during a global pandemic, that cleaning surfaces will significantly increase to once every three days, you know deep sanitization has never been a priority).

Shockingly, locals don’t see value in paying $2.75 to journey in a cesspool of human feces and rats the size of dachshunds either, so they jump turnstiles in full view of the busy-on-TikTok station staff.

6 OF 15

A Quick Trader Joe’s Shop Requires at Least an Hour

If you want to avoid the high prices of bodegas, you have to shop at Trader Joe’s. The problem is everyone else is doing the same, so shopping for essentials turns into an hour-long weight-lifting session whereby you pick your basket up and down over and over ‘til you reach the front of the line. Because the city has turned you into a raging alcoholic you also need TJ’s wine, but the only store that stocks it is in Union Square. It’s separate from the regular store, and the line is even longer.

7 OF 15

Pizzerias Lie in Their Marketing

Every single New York publication and book will recommend the “best pizza in the New York,” but the trouble is they all recommend a different pizzeria. The definition of “best” is the most excellent, the number one. It’s impossible to have 500 number one pizzerias. Nevertheless, this doesn’t stop 500 pizzerias labeling themselves the “best pizza in New York,” complete with signage at the front door.

8 OF 15

New Yorkers Can Be Extremely Argumentative About New York

When you argue with a New Yorker, prepare to lose even when you’re right. It’s as if they’re in a cult, and the core commandment is “New York is the greatest place on earth.” Disagree and you are burned at the stake. I’d like to hear them out (you have no choice since they are shouting), but I’ve known so many that have only traveled to three cities their whole lives, all within North America, that it makes them hard to be taken seriously.

9 OF 15

The Trash Is Everywhere

If you’ve ever seen an episode of Hoarders you’ll understand when I say NYC is an explosion of mess, not just of regular ol’ garbage like bottles and take-out boxes, but literally anything and everything, splashed across the sidewalk, the park, and the beach. You can go to a posh neighborhood like Chelsea and still step on a whole dead cat, a heap of used tampons, and an expired purple cauliflower quicker than you can say, “Not today, De Blasio.” There is no escape.

10 OF 15

Coney Island’s Beaches Are Packed and Filthy

You could compare Coney Island with a beach, or you could compare Coney Island with a landfill. I choose the latter. The water is a smoothie of contaminated soil, marine fuel, and the occasional sharp object, while the sand contains more eroded plastic forks than seashells. Amazingly the risk of bacterial infection does nothing to warn super-immune New Yorkers, and between June and September, every inch of wasteland, I mean sand, is covered over with counterfeit Peppa Pig towels and Tupperware.

11 OF 15

So-Called Pals Will Holiday in the Hamptons Without You

If you’re an Upper East Side millionaire or have a first name that rhymes with Melania, then your beaches are in the Hamptons, situated at the tip of Long Island. There it’s clean because it’s unreachable by LIRR/Amtrak /Greyhound and too expensive for regular New Yorkers to stay overnight. Maybe a colleague whose daddy plays golf with so-and-so from Tesla will one day slip a “Oh my gah, we should all go to the Hamptons together!” during Wasabi lunch, but rest assured she will not mean it. Come summer, the prettier people from the office have disappeared early on Friday and you’ve spent the whole weekend on your secret IG account watching their stories alone in your apartment.

12 OF 15

Outdoor Festive Occasions Are Torture

Expats know all too well that when folks back home come and visit, they book around festive “spectacles” like the ball drop, the Rockefeller tree lighting, and Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade. Not only do they assume you have front row access to all these events (you don’t), but they also assume you’ll have a blast accompanying them out in the freezing cold. Next thing you know, you’re watching Glee’s Lea Michele with a severely-weakened bladder for the second time in two weeks and you still don’t own a Planet Fitness hat.

13 OF 15

The City Soundtrack Will Drive You Insane

No point making a “New York, New York” playlist because the soundtrack to your new life in the city will be police sirens and taxi horns, all day every day, no matter where on the map you are.

In the four weeks of the year when you can actually sleep with your windows open and not drench the sheets in sweat/get frostbite on your nipples, you’re blasted with excruciating noise pollution through dawn, and then you have the drilling. Oh, the drilling. Well…now you understand why everyone’s lost their cheer.

14 OF 15

There’s Nowhere to Enjoy Good Coffee

Groggy after a rough night’s sleep? Unless you live between Columbia University and the top of Prospect Park, invest in a machine and an illy subscription, because your best nearby options will be Dunkin’ Donuts and Chock Full o’Nuts. For those lucky to live by a cute artisan coffee shop, you’ll savor the flavors of that $7 flat white walking-there will be no available seats inside, and hanging around outside means you only enjoy the fleshy ground coffee with freshly fermenting trash (told you it was everywhere).

15 OF 15

You Have to Be on Guard Each Time You Leave the Front Door

It goes without saying that you need to be vigilant against street crime in New York but what newbies don’t realize is that in addition, you have to worry about people you work with, do business with, sleep with, and live with. Whether it’s a colleague stealing your ideas, restaurants adding an extra bottle to your tab, landlords screwing you for the security deposit, or one-night-stands booking their Uber home on your phone, life in New York is a never-ending hustle and quite frankly, exhausting. It’s okay to admit you hate New York because trust me, New York hates you right back.

amandaporche3301 October 29, 2021

To write this you must have money . Everyone I know lives with multiple roommates and can't afford the hamptoms . I don't get the fake friend stuff either . Maybe you hang around the wrong people . I almost laughed at the high crime part . It is one of the safest big cities in US . They gun crime is ridiculously low and I have never been robbed or felt a threat of it . And the other commented complaining about homeless people , there are homeless people in every city and the are not a threat to you or anyone . Just walk past and don't give them money or give them money . I share cigarettes with homeless people all the time . Drugs are in every city since this country has terrible rehab programs and most jobs refuse to pay a living wage and jobs are hard to find . 

gypsyrose9529 July 11, 2021

Fodors I cannot believe you're posting this as a serious article. So many falsehoods and exaggerations. Pretty sure he picked out his 6 floor walk up all by himself but sure every apartment sucks bc his did. What really got my husband and I laughing though was number 11. After 10 paragraphs about how he hates New York and New Yorkers he had the balls to whine that nobody would invite him to their vacation home 😆 😂 😭 😭 😭 

New York isn't for everybody, clearly, but acting like it's unlivable for everybody is comedy at best and sad at its worst

oh and who can't find a good cup of coffee in New York City? I think that says more about the guy writing the article then anything else.

isham2w8431 July 1, 2021

New York is for the birds if you're not rich, good luck living paycheck-to-paycheck. And by the way, there was an article written last year stating that New York is the rudest city in America. And you have to watch it back late at night on the train station with homeless people begging for money and food, smoking K2 and sleeping in the subway cars as if its their living room. If you live in the minority neighborhoods forgot about sleeping. You have to constantly call the cops on fireworks, motorcycle street racers and loud music. ( By-the-way) I'm African-American and born and raised in New York City. I seen the good and bad

vicentevincent April 29, 2021

I was born in NYC. lived there for 63 years. I found this article funny and though exaggerated for comic effect, not totally off the mark. Coney is a zoo in the summer, the water is forbidding and always cold. When you have almsot 9 million people living in 300 sq miles, things can get dirty and certainly the summers can be brutal. It is not a city for the asthtically sensitive. It is untilitarian. It is by most standards, an unattractive city. 
Successs is in your face. If you're not successful, you know and wear it daily. People are like energizer bunnies with batteries that never wear out. It's fast paced, but undoubtably interesting. As a writer, though now in Florida, most of the backdrops for my stories are urban. 
As for the art scene, it is packed. If you're thinking of coming for the music scene, to get in front of an audience, be aware that every third person( It seems) has the same idea. 
Crowded? You bet. Packed. And though the subways can stand more updating, they are great compared to years ago. Too, the parks are terrific. I was always in central park. It is fantastic. You can walk 5th avenue along the park or walk central park west or south and find your walk peaceful and scenic. And street fairs galore and festive occasions and celebrations of ethnicity and art. 
Very expensive, but rent stabilzation makes it doable for many.

bigapplerules April 28, 2021

Tsk tsk.... no friends?... maybe nobody liked you
NYC is better off without you!
  Come on Fodor's... you are supposed to be a travel site not a forum for sour griping.