Fodor's Expert Review Jen's Island Café and Deli

$$ Charlotte Amalie American Fodor's Choice

Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.

This hole-in-the-wall eatery is the closest thing you can find to a New York–style Jewish deli, serving staples like smoked salmon and hot pastrami on rye. The deli also offers local specials like fresh snapper served whole in a creole sauce. Homemade desserts such as mango cheesecake and key lime pie are yummy. There's no parking nearby, so come on foot or by cab.

American Casual Breakfast Lunch $$ Fodor's Choice Family

Quick Facts

43–46 Norre Gade
Charlotte Amalie, Saint Thomas  00802, U.S. Virgin Islands


Known For:
  • Homemade desserts
  • Deli-style sandwiches
  • No parking nearby
Restaurant Details:
Rate Includes: Closed Sun. No dinner

What’s Nearby