National Parks closed - so what happens now?
#1
Original Poster
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 4,757
Likes: 0
National Parks closed - so what happens now?
During this period of time that the parks are closed, what happens to the people that have/had reservations and are staying in the hotels IN the park? Are they kicked out? What do they do for food and service - can't leave the park because they couldn't get back in, right? What about the back-country campers/hikers - do they round them up and send them out of the park. What actually happens when the government shuts down the parks?
#3
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 11,752
Likes: 17
The latest word from Xanterra who runs most of the lodging:
http://www.xanterra.com/news/potenti...ment-shutdown/
Some of the National Parks have state highways through them that can't be closed.
http://www.xanterra.com/news/potenti...ment-shutdown/
Some of the National Parks have state highways through them that can't be closed.
#5
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
"Ideally, they would all go home and file recall petitions against the idiotic congressmen who made this happen."
I would think level-headed people would be asking why they even need to be closed. Park Police are law enforcement and public safety positions, so they should still be there. Other than that, are there any other federal government employees who are absolutely necessary to be there for people to go on a hike. No, there aren't. The food and lodging are operated by outside businesses, so there's no real reason why they would need to close.
How about the Lincoln Memorial? It's essentially some steps leading to a statue. In normal times, nobody is there, other than maybe Park Police in the general vicinity. So why would there be a need to take the extra effort to wall it off? Is there spending that occurs on a day to day basis that is necessary to allow people to walk up the steps and look at the statue?
The answer to all of this is no and none. It is being done not by necessity, but out of spite, as a punishment. Ideally, people would start to question that.
I would think level-headed people would be asking why they even need to be closed. Park Police are law enforcement and public safety positions, so they should still be there. Other than that, are there any other federal government employees who are absolutely necessary to be there for people to go on a hike. No, there aren't. The food and lodging are operated by outside businesses, so there's no real reason why they would need to close.
How about the Lincoln Memorial? It's essentially some steps leading to a statue. In normal times, nobody is there, other than maybe Park Police in the general vicinity. So why would there be a need to take the extra effort to wall it off? Is there spending that occurs on a day to day basis that is necessary to allow people to walk up the steps and look at the statue?
The answer to all of this is no and none. It is being done not by necessity, but out of spite, as a punishment. Ideally, people would start to question that.
Trending Topics
#8




Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 44,606
Likes: 3
Call Rep Bachmann from Minnesota and ask her to come and remove any barricades to camping grounds, monuments, the Liberty Bell, etc.
You need to dress like a veteran, preferably without arms and legs in a wheelchair so the photo op will make sense to her.
You need to dress like a veteran, preferably without arms and legs in a wheelchair so the photo op will make sense to her.
#11
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 2,304
Likes: 0
"Park Police are law enforcement and public safety positions, so they should still be there. Other than that, are there any other federal government employees who are absolutely necessary to be there for people to go on a hike. No, there aren't."
It's not as simple as that.
First, I don't believe that all park rangers are law enforcement/public safety officers as well. There are a lot of rangers that work the entrance booths and visitor centers. With no visitors, those positions all stay home. Even some of the rangers that would normally be out patrolling can stay home as well, since it's much easier to patrol a park with no humans in it.
So, if the parks simply stayed open but closed the visitor centers and let everyone in free, they would need to staff the law enforcement and public safety positions at the normal levels. And that would violate the whole 'non-essential' part of the shutdown, because the government doesn't view hiking as an essential activity.
As for the backcountry campers, I would assume that parks were warning them of the possibility of a government shutdown and telling them they might need to vacate if it did happen. I would guess there were rangers assigned to locate all the permit holders today and inform them of the shutdown and give them til nightfall to exit the park.
It's not as simple as that.
First, I don't believe that all park rangers are law enforcement/public safety officers as well. There are a lot of rangers that work the entrance booths and visitor centers. With no visitors, those positions all stay home. Even some of the rangers that would normally be out patrolling can stay home as well, since it's much easier to patrol a park with no humans in it.
So, if the parks simply stayed open but closed the visitor centers and let everyone in free, they would need to staff the law enforcement and public safety positions at the normal levels. And that would violate the whole 'non-essential' part of the shutdown, because the government doesn't view hiking as an essential activity.
As for the backcountry campers, I would assume that parks were warning them of the possibility of a government shutdown and telling them they might need to vacate if it did happen. I would guess there were rangers assigned to locate all the permit holders today and inform them of the shutdown and give them til nightfall to exit the park.
#12
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 510
Likes: 0
Campers have 48 hours to get out - Federal Parks are closed - Statue of Liberty for example - CLOSED. We will be in NYC in mid Oct and have already bought tickets to the ferry to SOL - hoping all is ironed out and " again - bring on elections!!
#19
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 9,171
Likes: 0
Just an observation but I was at Yellowstone in August and a lot of the workers were from out of the country. They all wore labels saying where they were from. I wonder what happens to them. They must be on some sort of foreign exchange program. Nice lodges and restaurants. Hope they gave away all the food to the workers.


