Both are highly rated but can anyone comment on either or both, especially as a comparison?

Are you trying to compare Miraval and Canyon Ranch? Both highly rated, top notch spas in Tucson.

I agree, both Canyon ranch and Mirival are both very, very nice top rated spas. Don't know about any Green vally spa, but whatever it is it would not compare to the other two. Both are always in Conde Naste spelling? As top of the top.

I also have never heard of a "Green Vally" spa, so You should stick with either Canyon Ranch or Miraval. I think you would be delighted with either one.

Having stayed at the Green Valley Spa I can tell you it is wonderful. Though I am not sure it is in comparison to the other 2 mentioned. It is located in St. george and was the award ont the family edition of the biggest losser on NBC. I loved staying there. There products are the best. But again I think the others are nicer and probably with a bigger pricetag.

I was also going to ask if it was the Green Valley Spa in St George, UT that rorand was asking about. If so, it is supposed to be one of the best in the country. I have seen them give it away as a trip on Regis and Kelly before.