Milford plaza - good choice or Bad
#1
Guest
Posts: n/a
Milford plaza - good choice or Bad
I am taking my wife and four children to New York for the 1st time in March 2001, for three days.
Have provisionally on the advice of others made provisional reservations at the Milford Plaza. I am getting conflicting reports on hotel can any one advise or suggest any other hotel.
Have provisionally on the advice of others made provisional reservations at the Milford Plaza. I am getting conflicting reports on hotel can any one advise or suggest any other hotel.
#2
Guest
Posts: n/a
Zagat's, one of my favorite ratings guides because it uses the ratings of a lot of individuals as opposed to one writer, lists the Milford as one of the worst in America.
My last experience there was 10 years ago so much may have changed since then. My room was filthy, small, and noisy. The front desk staff couldn't care less and actually told me "you get what you pay for." Truer words were never spoken!
My last experience there was 10 years ago so much may have changed since then. My room was filthy, small, and noisy. The front desk staff couldn't care less and actually told me "you get what you pay for." Truer words were never spoken!
#5
Guest
Posts: n/a
My husband and I recently stayed at the Best Western Woodward hotel. The rooms were very nice and we only paid $130. It is only a few blocks from time square. We had a great time! We also just booked a hotel using priceline. They gave us a room at the Marriott eastside for $130. I actually called the hotel to check rates and they told me the cheapest was $395!! Hope this helps!
#9
Guest
Posts: n/a
I stayed up in NYC for 2 weeks for work and stayed at the Milford Plaza the entire time. The rooms are small and cramped, however it did not really bother me, but it might with 4 kids. The location is wonderful for times square and the theatre district and the subway stop is about 1/2 block away. My room overlooked Times Square. I didn't have any problems with the front desk staff or anyone in the hotel for that matter. My opinon: Wonderful for the price, but not so hot for a family of 4.
#10
Guest
Posts: n/a
Hi Ian,
I recommendation I see here alot is the Radio City apartments. This might better suit your needs. A couple of bedrooms, living room and kitchen.
www.radiocityapartments.com. Do a search here you'll find other opinions.
I recommendation I see here alot is the Radio City apartments. This might better suit your needs. A couple of bedrooms, living room and kitchen.
www.radiocityapartments.com. Do a search here you'll find other opinions.
#11
Guest
Posts: n/a
Ian, the Ramada Milford Plaza IS the one and only Milford Plaza. (one is enough...God forbid TWO Milford Plazas!) I think it used to be a Best Western at one time. Ramada's just the chain that got stuck with this dump at this date and time...it'll change again!
#13
Guest
Posts: n/a
Definitely look elsewhere. i stayed there 1 year ago. There were cockroaches, dirty linen, it was a nightmare. I also hooked up with lots of Broadway frequent visitors and they ALL (about 50 of them) had had terrible experiences there. Go to the Edison Hotel. Cheaper, same size rooms, but cleaner. Good luck.
#14
Guest
Posts: n/a
I've never stayed at the Milford Plaza but have heard not-so-good things about it. I remember years back (in the 80's?)Milford Plaza had the corniest, world's worst TV commercial(I lived in the city at time), and I thought to myself that I would never stay in a place that had such jerky advertising.
#16
Guest
Posts: n/a
Ian: We have stayed at the Helmley Windsor many times and will stay there again. The rooms are quiet large for New York, it is always clean and they are quiet friendly. We also like the location. This is an older but well kept property. Hope this helps.
#17
Guest
Posts: n/a
I was just in New York and stayed at the Best Western Manhatten. I think with kids it would not be my choice. I,m not saying its bad but it would be better to be in a place where you have choices fo restaurants. I,m sure someone on here can help you. I think it would be better to be around the theater district, time square and lots of restaurants, maybe Radio City.
I think if you loook back a few days you will see messages of another family coming to NY and where to stay.
I think if you loook back a few days you will see messages of another family coming to NY and where to stay.
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
Ian, that's a good rate for that hotel. You'll be at a very convenient location---close to Times Square and the theater district, Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center, Central Park, etc. The Sheraton New York is a major convention hotel (i.e., where people going to conventions stay, not the site of the actual conventions). It's safe. You made a wise move in switching hotels.