I once posted requesting advice on where the best key lime pie could be found. Alot of the answers said in the Florida Keys. Well, we have our trip planned now, and I can't find the post! Going in February, spending one night in Marathon,then 3 nights Key West.
I wanted to check the key lime pie tour post so I could write down the recommendations but I can't find the post. So please repost your suggestions for Marathon and Key West. Thank you.

My vote is for key lime pie on a stick with a chocolate crust covered in chocolate at Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shoppe in Key West.

Manny & Lisa's Kitchen in Islamorada has very good Key Lime pie, MM #81.6 ocean side. Mangrove Mama's in Summerland Key, MM #19-20 is another one. There is Key West Key Lime Pie factory on the corner of Caroline & Greene Streets that has fresh pie & stuff fresh baked daily & is very good. The Blond Giraffe, The Sublime Key Lime Pie Company is another one at 629 Duval St. There factory is located on Stock Island. If you want a great breakfast try the Cracked Egg in Big Pine Key.

Best key lime pie is at Sloppy Joe's in Key West - smooth, creamy and just tart enough - its the best I've ever had.

The Blonde Giraff and beleive it or not, Outback Steakhouse. It comes in a square and it is homemade. They put nuts in the crust.

Kermit's is across the street from the Waterfront area and is really good. He's a nice guy too, we talked to him while we were in there. The Blonde Giraffe is also good. I think the frozen choc ones on a stick are better than regular pie on a plate.