We stayed at the Grand Hyatt and the Marriott in Lihue (hotel) last October. We liked the Hyatt a lot, thought the Marriott was a little "worn". The price differential is pretty large I think, in recognition of the difference in overall quality. The Hyatt rooms had just been refurbished when we were there.

Again, thanks so much for your help. You've been great. We've nearly committed to the Waikiki Beach Marriott Resort. The rest of our trip requires more thought, I think. I'm reading about all the islands; it's relaxing just to read what each island offers!

Figuring out where to stay in Waikiki was the easy part since you were choosing between three places. Now the real challenge begins!

Exactly.

While both are beautiful, my heart belongs to Maui. I think Maui is a nice blend of all the islands. There is enough to do, if you are so inclined, or just enjoy and relax.

Am having the same problem making a decision as the OP!!! I realise this is an old thread but thought it would be a good idea to revive it. Any other opinions between the two islands.