Why do you say americans to people from USA?
#1
Original Poster
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Why do you say americans to people from USA?
I don't want to generate problems but:
Why do you say "americans" to people from USA?
I am from Argentina and I hate when I hear people calling american to a USA person because people from Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay, Brasil, Honduras, Nicaragua, Cuba, etc, are also "americans".
I propose to call them US people.
Good bye and thanks for reading my post
Why do you say "americans" to people from USA?
I am from Argentina and I hate when I hear people calling american to a USA person because people from Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay, Brasil, Honduras, Nicaragua, Cuba, etc, are also "americans".
I propose to call them US people.
Good bye and thanks for reading my post

#6

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 35,152
Likes: 0
well, if you hate it don't do it. I know people from South and Central America (several countries) and they don't want to be called Americans, I'm surprised you do.
Why does one say that? Because it's just historical custom, and a shortening of the full name of the country, is that difficult to understand? The name of the country is United States of America. It isn't because that is also part of the continent's name. I know people from Central America who routinely call Americans that in Spanish (americanos), even when speaking in their own language to each other, in reference to them, not because anyone is making them or because any are even nearby. They would never use that term to refer to a Cuban. I have friends from Peru and Uruguay and neither would ever refer to themself as an "American". Do you refer to Mexicans as US people since the name of their country is offically United Mexican States (Estados Unidos Mexicanos?)
Why does one say that? Because it's just historical custom, and a shortening of the full name of the country, is that difficult to understand? The name of the country is United States of America. It isn't because that is also part of the continent's name. I know people from Central America who routinely call Americans that in Spanish (americanos), even when speaking in their own language to each other, in reference to them, not because anyone is making them or because any are even nearby. They would never use that term to refer to a Cuban. I have friends from Peru and Uruguay and neither would ever refer to themself as an "American". Do you refer to Mexicans as US people since the name of their country is offically United Mexican States (Estados Unidos Mexicanos?)
Trending Topics
#9
Original Poster
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Yes Cristina. Most of people from South and Central America call them "americanos" but it is WRONG.
When I ask them why they call americanos they look at me a few seconds and say: I don't know...
We are loosing more identity. It's like if I call european to people from the England.
When I ask them why they call americanos they look at me a few seconds and say: I don't know...
We are loosing more identity. It's like if I call european to people from the England.
#10
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 4,874
Likes: 0
I have considered this issue. When I was asked my nationality while in Italy, I always said "US", although that sounds awkward. Of course, "American" would have given the same result; what they really wanted to know is if we were from an EU country (thus, entitling our kids to a student discount); they didn't care if we were from Costa Rica or Chile or the US - still no discount.
#13
Original Poster
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Christina: what I only want is to call them US-ians or US people or something else but not americans because we are aaall americans (north, central and south).
They are from US, America. I'm from Argentina, America. It's easy...
They are from US, America. I'm from Argentina, America. It's easy...
#14
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 3,227
Likes: 0
I'm Spanish...I call American everyone when I want to refer to the whole continent...the same I do with Europeans (including UK and Ireland!!).
So, I am european and spanish, I can't see the problem. Maybe the english language is the problem..we have a name for the US people in spanish "estadounidenses"
So, I am european and spanish, I can't see the problem. Maybe the english language is the problem..we have a name for the US people in spanish "estadounidenses"
#18
Original Poster
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Yes Kenderina, may be a part of the problem is the english language but not at all. Here are people that call "americanos" to US people.
I think this is part of the imperialist politics that they instaled in all over the continent.
I think this is part of the imperialist politics that they instaled in all over the continent.
#19

Joined: May 2005
Posts: 11,236
Likes: 1
Good question. This has been discussed before on another thread.
They: Where are you from?
I: USA
They: Ah, America. Where?
I: Washington State
They: Ah, Washington DC
I: No, Washington State. Seattle. Bill Gates.
They: Ah (as they look away with boredom)
I: I grew up three hours south of Vancouver.
They: Ah, Vancouver Canada. Beautiful.
It's a no-win situation. And I still don't know why they associate "America" with the USA only.
They: Where are you from?
I: USA
They: Ah, America. Where?
I: Washington State
They: Ah, Washington DC
I: No, Washington State. Seattle. Bill Gates.
They: Ah (as they look away with boredom)
I: I grew up three hours south of Vancouver.
They: Ah, Vancouver Canada. Beautiful.
It's a no-win situation. And I still don't know why they associate "America" with the USA only.

