Coronavirus in Spain
#45
Joined: Oct 2018
Posts: 35
Likes: 0
If an infected person sneezes in front of you, washing your hands won't matter but a good mask can still help.
#46

Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 2,057
Likes: 0
#48

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 4,942
Likes: 0
Last edited by Moderator1; Mar 1st, 2020 at 08:46 PM. Reason: removed political comment not travel related
#50
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 9,773
Likes: 0
" We are in a pandemic" That is a very categoric assertion? So who exactly has declared this a "pandemic" WHO, CDC, NHS or just menachem? If indeed you are an epidemiologist then please do declare your qualifications and experience but I somehow doubt that any professional worth their salt would be posting such comments on a travel forum
Last edited by Moderator1; Mar 1st, 2020 at 08:47 PM. Reason: deleted quote of a deleted comment
#51

Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 2,057
Likes: 0
The Chinese companies canceled because of their own health issues.
The American companies started canceling just because a big international show is always a bit of a risk. You don't fly halfway around the world to stand two metres away from somebody wearing a mask. Making sure not to shake their hand.
Then the European companies canceled.
The show itself wasn't canceled because at the time Barcelona had infections but because nobody was willing to risk dealing with that sort of environment. That leaves the government stating it wasn't canceled because of local health issues. True. But it was still canceled because the result of worldwide health issues. True.
#52

Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
Just want to clarify......COVID-19 is not "far less deadly than the flu". Although the mortality rate is a preliminary estimate at this point, it is higher than that of the flu. Perhaps you meant to say that the risk of being infected with COVID-19 is less than the risk of getting the flu? That is true.
I agree that at this point the biggest worry would be getting stuck in quarantine. I guess we will see how things unfold.
I agree that at this point the biggest worry would be getting stuck in quarantine. I guess we will see how things unfold.
#53

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 4,942
Likes: 0
" We are in a pandemic" That is a very categoric assertion? So who exactly has declared this a "pandemic" WHO, CDC, NHS or just menachem? If indeed you are an epidemiologist then please do declare your qualifications and experience but I somehow doubt that any professional worth their salt would be posting such comments on a travel forum
#54
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 9,773
Likes: 0
The problem with banning travel air, rail or bus, is the effect that it will have on the world economy which is already showing signs of a serious downturn and will have a knock on effect on the wealth, health and well being of much of the world and as usual, it will be the poorest that will suffer the most. Closing down palces of employment, transport etc will also have a serious effect upon the ability of hospitals and medical professionals to deal with this problem.
sometimes it is necessary to take a look at the wider issues and how to deal with all of them and not just panic about the immediate problem. Governments I am afraid are being driven by social media and the press into making knee jerk reactions.
Last edited by Moderator1; Mar 2nd, 2020 at 08:13 PM. Reason: deleted off topic comment about moderation
#55

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 35,167
Likes: 0
People believe what they want, such as those making silly comparisons to the flu (ie, more people die from the flu so I shouldn't be worried, Trump is making similar statements, which shows you). The current estimates of the mortality rate from Covid19 are much much higher than the flu. Raw numbers of people is irrelevant, more people die from the flu just because it is much more common and more widespread in the world, but Covid19 currently has a fatality rate about 20 times higher. The fatality rate from the flu is fairly low, about 0.1%. Even public health officials don't know as much about Covid19 yet, either, including exactly how it is transmitted, etc. In both viruses, many cases go unreported of course, most flu cases aren't reported, either,, so that doesn't account for why statistics are not good on Covid19 but are for the flu (ie, the argument that some mild cases aren't counted in the denominator because they aren't reported).
If you are young and healthy, you can be more cavalier, I wouldn't worry that much in that case if I were going to an area without a major breakout yet. Italy as a lot of cases, they are really growing. I personally would not choose to go to an area right now with a lot of cases for vacation. It ios affecting a lot of things, even if you think you are somehow immune from getting it and don't care if you do.
I think traveling in general amongst a lot of people in airplanes, etc., is not great for health reasons. Hopefully, this will subside in the summer and they will learn more about it, also. But they don't even know if it will have seasonality like the flu, and experts don't even agree on why that has seasonality. Some coronaviruses don't, like MERS, and appear in warm weather climates, anyway,
Covid19 is clearly not "like the flu", I don't know why anyone is even arguing with that. It isn't the same type of virus. WHO hasn't declared this a pandemic, though, that's for sure. It is good news that the number of new cases in China is dropping a lot.
https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/heal...019-vs-the-flu
If you are young and healthy, you can be more cavalier, I wouldn't worry that much in that case if I were going to an area without a major breakout yet. Italy as a lot of cases, they are really growing. I personally would not choose to go to an area right now with a lot of cases for vacation. It ios affecting a lot of things, even if you think you are somehow immune from getting it and don't care if you do.
I think traveling in general amongst a lot of people in airplanes, etc., is not great for health reasons. Hopefully, this will subside in the summer and they will learn more about it, also. But they don't even know if it will have seasonality like the flu, and experts don't even agree on why that has seasonality. Some coronaviruses don't, like MERS, and appear in warm weather climates, anyway,
Covid19 is clearly not "like the flu", I don't know why anyone is even arguing with that. It isn't the same type of virus. WHO hasn't declared this a pandemic, though, that's for sure. It is good news that the number of new cases in China is dropping a lot.
https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/heal...019-vs-the-flu
#56

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 4,942
Likes: 0
I agree that the best thing is to "flatten the curve" as you put it. However, many medical "experts" seem now to be questioning whether self isolation, banning events, restricting travel is actually working or will work and that letting the virus run its course may be the best or only option. i.e. the curve will flatten naturally.
The problem with banning travel air, rail or bus, is the effect that it will have on the world economy which is already showing signs of a serious downturn and will have a knock on effect on the wealth, health and well being of much of the world and as usual, it will be the poorest that will suffer the most. Closing down palces of employment, transport etc will also have a serious effect upon the ability of hospitals and medical professionals to deal with this problem.
sometimes it is necessary to take a look at the wider issues and how to deal with all of them and not just panic about the immediate problem. Governments I am afraid are being driven by social media and the press into making knee jerk reactions.
The problem with banning travel air, rail or bus, is the effect that it will have on the world economy which is already showing signs of a serious downturn and will have a knock on effect on the wealth, health and well being of much of the world and as usual, it will be the poorest that will suffer the most. Closing down palces of employment, transport etc will also have a serious effect upon the ability of hospitals and medical professionals to deal with this problem.
sometimes it is necessary to take a look at the wider issues and how to deal with all of them and not just panic about the immediate problem. Governments I am afraid are being driven by social media and the press into making knee jerk reactions.
Yes, the curve will flatten naturally, but how many dead do we want to allow for that?
Last edited by Moderator1; Mar 2nd, 2020 at 08:15 PM. Reason: deleted reference to a deleted comment
#57

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 1,830
Likes: 0
These people seem to know a lot about this virus and they are making also silly comparisons with flu, https://www.livescience.com/new-coro...-with-flu.html. What is true is that the risk of getting infected is extremely low, according to the actual figures. But, again, every individual may decide on his/her own attitude towards this virus, as itīs worldwide spread now it seems that no matter what you do, you have chances of getting infected.
#59

Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 1,830
Likes: 0
Just been to an informative lecture on coronavirus, by and epidemiologist and a "preventionist", a post I did not it existed, here in Bilbao in the Public Health System, aimed at all kind of persons but especially at medical staff and workers (a friend of mine is a nurse and I could get in). Well, it does not affect kids under 6, thatīs good news. Also, the most affected patients in the world are men, around 45 year old, with a global mortality rate of just 0.3%, that increases to a scarce 0.6% to people over 65, if in good health. Those with a higher death rate, around 1.6% at present, are persons with previous ilnesses and in weak condition, mainly respiratory diseases in various degrees, and diabetics. All deaths have been considered, worldly, but rate is lower in first world countries, for obvious reasons. Means of contaging: mainly, hands. Masks may be contraproducent, as we touch our noses when installing them, or mouths, and itīs the way the virus enters into your system. Sneezing, coughing...yes, itīs another way, but just to the length of your arm, it produces dry cough and it does not go over a meter off your body, with thick drops (safer), instead of thinner ones (as those in SARS virus, more contagious). Two weeks approx between contagion and symptoms, then it goes very quickly, and also disappears very quickly. Itīs another way of flu, so they are recommending just paracetamol. Itīs thought to be originated in the pangolin, a mammal that lives in China and chinese have as a meal, they way it has possible passed onto humans. Right now, very low risk of infection and spreading, compared to measles or standard flu, and they expect it to follow the same path of flu, that is, it should be insignificant by spring this year. Vaccines are already being tested, but nothing definite yet. Thatīs basically what I can remember of this interesting talk today, hope it helps.
Last edited by mikelg; Mar 3rd, 2020 at 08:10 AM.



