Having a hard time deciding between:
Beachcomber, Treasure Island, & Plantana. I've looked at all three (on-line) and they all seem very nice. Is one truly nicer (better beach, amenities, etc) than the
other(s)?

I'd go with Plantana. It's on the best stretch of 7 mile beach. that's where we are staying in Feb.

Beach at Beachcomber and Plantana are better than the beach at TI. They are within a 5 minute walk of each other. A nother one to consider is Villa of the Galleons.

Another vote for Plantana. Haven't stayed ther yet, but it always gets great reviews. We did walk around the grounds this past June and it seems very nice. Great beach, small pool-but beach is more important to me.

We just got back from a week at the Beachcomber. It was wonderful! It's in the best location and the beach was wonderful! You are also right across the street from a grocery store, pharmacy, restaurants and other stores. We would definitely stay at the Beachcomber when we go back and nowhere else!

Also, if you have any specific questions about the Beachcomber, email me at [email protected], I'd be happy to help!

Definitely Plantana or Villas of the Galleon. Nicest condos on the best stretch of beach in the best location.

What is the best site to search for condos?

caymanvacations.com

You can also try gotocayman.com. This way you can directly log on to the website of the different condos.