Thanks to Tom for bringing this page to our attention.
http://www.fodors.com/wire/archives/002208.cfm

...but alas...that list is woefully lacking! Oh the horror!

As Blamona said : "The great thing about Fodor's, is they have these forums, and us to correct things! "

So...which restaurants would YOU add to that list?

Coyoba's in Turks and Caicos.
Any restaurant in Grand Case, St. Martin. (Almost any restaurant in all of St. Martin French side actually)
Mangos in Anguilla.

I have to agree with Blamona. You cannot mention the Caribbean and leave out St Martin. The restaurants there are just fabulous.

I agree with many of their selections, however, leaving out St. Martin is a crime!

I would also add some restaurants in Old San Juan. I have always had wonderful meals there.

Well, I've only been to one of the restaurants on the Fodor's list, but based on what I've read of the others, I do not disagree with the other selections. They didn't post it as the 10 best restaurants, after all. Just 10 that are worth the splurge.

As for being worth the splurge, I guess I'd add Montpelier on Nevis. But truthfully, many of the best meals I've eaten in the Caribbean weren't splurges at all!

Havana Blue, Virgilio's & sometimes Old Stone Farmhouse on St. Thomas.