Pennsylvania Dutch Country Restaurants

Like the German cuisine that influenced it, Pennsylvania Dutch cooking is hearty and uses ingredients from local farms. Though their numbers are dwindling, there are still a few traditional Pennsylvania Dutch restaurants where you can dine family style. Lancaster County has numerous reasonably priced family restaurants, along with a number of eateries offering more exotic fare. The cuisine is changing and expanding to include many flavors beyond traditional Amish. Unless otherwise noted, liquor is served.

Sort by: 8 Recommendations {{numTotalPoiResults}} {{ (numTotalPoiResults===1)?'Recommendation':'Recommendations' }} 0 Recommendations
CLEAR ALL Area Search CLEAR ALL
Loading...
  • 1. Annie Bailey's Irish Public House

    $$

    Located in a Victorian-era building in downtown Lancaster, Annie Bailey's is a traditional Irish pub, from the dark wooden bar and furnishings sourced in Ireland to classic menu staples like shepherd's pie and fish-and-chips. There are at least 10 rotating beers on tap and an impressive selection Irish whiskey. The owners have transformed the second floor into Conway Social Club, a speakeasy (you knock and wait for the green light to enter) serving craft cocktails and globally inspired small plates.

    28–30 E. King St., Lancaster, Pennsylvania, 17602, USA
    717-393–4000

    Known For

    • Bangers and mash
    • Good selection of Irish beer
    • Vegetarian options
    • Irish curry

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • 2. Fourscore Beer Co.

    $

    This family-owned brewpub is located minutes from the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Center. Beers range from Double Citra Pillows (a hazy IPA) to Hiding in Plain Sight (a hoppy lager) and the menu includes appetizers, salads, and sandwiches.

    603 S. Washington St., Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, 17325, USA
    717-345--8171

    Known For

    • Beer-inspired menu items like hop hat mac and cheese
    • Nightly specials like wing Wednesday and trivia Thursday
    • Beers to-go available in cans and growlers

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Mon.--Tues.
  • 3. Hershey Pantry

    $$$

    This family-friendly restaurant is a beloved favorite among locals for its hearty breakfast lineup. Portions are generous, the menus are huge, and the food is unpretentious in a good-ole-diner sort of way. Reservations are not taken, and no is alcohol served, but they welcome BYOB.

    801 E. Chocolate Ave., Hershey, Pennsylvania, 17033, USA
    717-533–7505

    Known For

    • Hearty breakfast
    • Afternoon tea service
    • Huge selection of in-house desserts

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Closed Sun., No credit cards
  • 4. Lancaster Dispensing Co.

    $

    Locally known as Dipco, this welcoming pub next to Central Market is a fun haunt for a nosh and a pint, especially when there's live music on the weekends. Sandwiches, house-made chili, burritos, as well as nightly specials, are among the many menu options. The building, as is the case with so many in downtown Lancaster, is more than 100 years old.

    33–35 N. Market St., Lancaster, Pennsylvania, 17603, USA
    717-299–4602

    Known For

    • Nachos platters
    • Weekday happy hour
    • Extensive selection of baked dips

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • 5. Miller's Smorgasbord

    $$$$

    This buffet-style eatery has been a local institution since 1929, offering views of Amish farmland and enough food to satisfy any appetite. The spread here is lavish, with a good selection of Pennsylvania Dutch specialties at the daily smorgasbord. There's an à la carte menu, and even beer, wine, and spirits are now available. The attached shopping complex includes a quilt shop.

    2811 Lincoln Hwy. E, Ronks, Pennsylvania, 17572, USA
    800-669–3568

    Known For

    • Iced raisin bread
    • Chicken corn soup
    • Brown buttered noodles

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • Recommended Fodor’s Video

  • 6. Smokehouse BBQ and Brews at Plain & Fancy Farm

    $$$

    The newest dining option at the expansive Plain & Fancy Farm complex is catering to individual families and groups under 20. The menu is a variation on the traditional Amish theme, featuring various smoked meats, but still with many of the country sides like chowchow and pepper cabbage; the "Smokehouse Sampler," a fixed-price feast, is the heartiest offering. Beer and à la carte dining is also available. Also on the grounds are shops selling everything from quilts to baked goods, and attractions like the Amish Experience. For smaller groups interested in an all-you-can eat experience, Plain & Fancy's sister restaurant, Miller's Smorgasbord, is 3 miles away.

    3121 Old Philadelphia Pike, Bird-in-Hand, Pennsylvania, 17505, USA
    717-768–4400

    Known For

    • Smoked brisket
    • The "Smokehouse Sampler," a fixed-price feast
    • A variety of barbecue sauces

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • 7. The Cat's Meow

    $$$

    In a restored 1869 railroad hotel, this eatery has the atmosphere of a speakeasy from the Roaring '20s with newspapers from the era and gangster portraits adding to the period flavor. Entrées include broiled crab cakes, seafood pasta, and tenderloin tips on toast, a Lancaster County tavern favorite that dates to Prohibition, as well as items with some cutesy, Prohibition-era names like machine gun linguine and a flapper salad. The menu is huge, but there are a variety of plates both big and small.

    215 S. Charlotte St., Manheim, Pennsylvania, 17545, USA
    717-664–3370

    Known For

    • Speakeasy vibe
    • Huge menu with lots of options
    • Tenderloin tips on toast

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted
  • 8. The Pressroom

    $$$

    Originally a hardware store from the mid-1700s, this Victorian building in the center of town is now home to a casual bistro. It's owned by the company that also owns the local newspaper (hence the name) and is outfitted with a classic mahogany bar, tall leather booths, and an exposed baking hearth. Salads, sandwiches, and burgers dominate the menu, with a rotating selection of seasonally inspired dishes featuring local produce and meat. The Park Bar in the adjoining brick courtyard is lovely for cocktails and light fare in warm months.

    26–28 W. King St., Lancaster, Pennsylvania, 17603, USA
    717-399–5400

    Known For

    • Tacos de asada
    • Daily soup and quiche
    • Friendly vibe

    Restaurant Details

    Rate Includes: Credit cards accepted, Closed Mon.

No Restaurants Results

Please try a broader search, or expore these popular suggestions:

There are no results for {{ strDestName}} Restaurants in the searched map area with the above filters. Please try a different area on the map, or broaden your search with these popular suggestions:

Recommended Fodor’s Video