Fodor's Expert Review Neptune's Treasure

The owners, the Soares family, have lived on the island for more than half a century, and catch, cook, and serve the seafood at this homey bar and restaurant a short distance from Setting Point. The fresh lobster, swordfish, tuna, and mahimahi are all delicious. Pam's Kitchen, a small bakery, has been incorporated into the restaurant and rounds out offerings with freshly baked breads; sweet treats including made-from-scratch desserts (including key lime pie, chocolate brownies, and apple pie); and pizzas. Potent "Jungle Juice" is the happy hour drink of choice at the tiki bar on the beach. Dinner is by candlelight at the water's edge. Dinner reservations are essential by 4 pm.