Italy: What to Skip, and Where to Go Instead
By Sara Lieberman
Italy is a well-traversed country. Unlike less-trodden Croatia or Turkey, visitors from all over the world descend upon the boot in droves for an authentic taste of its homegrown specialties (olive oil! pesto!), Renaissance art, and gothic architecture.
So as you can imagine, finding lesser-known haunts and hidden gems can be a challenge. Rather than wait in lines to see art everyone else has seen, or taste gelato that everyone else has sampled, take the road less traveled. Some of Italy's most beaten paths, like the Amalfi Coast, Florence, and Pisa can (and should) be skipped in favor of more intriguing, less tour-bus-filled counterparts. Read on for the best alternatives.
Skip the Amalfi Coast, Try Cinque Terre
The legendary picturesque destination that is the Amalfi Coast exists in movies like The Talented Mr. Ripley—where limoncello is liberally poured at intimate coastal bars. In reality, you'll find more tourist busses than Jude Law types. Your best alternative? Cinque Terre (pictured above), or "five towns" set along the rocky northern coast overlooking the Ligurian sea. Once you reach La Spezia (just north of Pisa), each of the small five towns can be reached by foot or by train. What's more, they offer a feast for the five senses.
In the multi-colored village of Riomaggiore, the first of the towns from the south, venture along the Via dell'Amore. It got its name shortly after World War II, when this trail became a rendezvous point for lovers who lived in Riomaggiore and neighboring Manarola. Today, those who pass through leave padlocks as a nod to everlasting love. Continuing on, stop in sleepy Manarola. At the top of town, by the bell tower, you'll find a wooden railing with steps up to a vineyard path where you'll take in the scents of grapevines and lemons trees, while bumblebees whiz by and lizards scurry at your feet. The path leads down to the cemetery and then to the breakwater where you'll either continue along the trail, or if it's still closed due to recent landslides, catch a train to the next town.
Once arriving in Corniglia, you'll climb 365-steps to reach town; it's the only one of the five not in a harbor. It's worth the trek, if only for a midday glass of vino at Enoteca Il Pirun, which serves them in a funnel-like glass called a Pirun. Apparently, it allows the wine to breathe better. But it's also silly. (Plus, they give you a bib in case you dribble, which makes for great photos.) Walking along narrow passageways that hug the coast, you'll see Cinque Terre's best views as you make your way into Vernazza.
Vernazza is charming with windy streets and a mini beach with large rocks for sunbathing. Recently hit by a massive flood and landslide, it is still recovering from more than 100 million Euros in damage and the loss of three lives. Stop to listen to the waves crashing along the rocks before trekking along to the next town.The trek to Monterosso is the most strenuous, but it's worth the exercise as you'll want to do nothing but eat on arriving. (You'll also want to shell out a few Euro for a lounge chair at one of the beach clubs.) The biggest and most 'resort-y' of the five towns, you could easily stay the night. But first, try the simple and delicious lemon acciughe (anchovies) at Risorante Miky, the frutta di mare at L'Alta Marea, and the crema a limone gelato at Slurp! Gelato Artiganale.
Where to Stay: Stay in Vernazza if you want charm and intimacy. But if you also want views, be prepared to hike up stairs. Lots of them. Try Gianni Franzi, whose reception is located in Gianni Franzi Ristorante off the main drag of Piazza Marconi. Their 20 rooms vary in size, but are tucked away amid the carugas overlooking the breakwater. Rates from 70-100 Euro.
If you want modern and hip, the new Hotel Margherita in Monterosso's Old Town is where it's at. You'll get all the amenities—A/C, WiFi, satellite TV—in any of the 31 rooms. Rates from 80-230 Euro.
Skip Florence, Try Siena
You've heard about David's "package" and the gold on the Ponte Vecchio. You've read tips about navigating the streets between the Uffizi Gallery and the Duomo, and you've seen photos of the bistecca fiorentina at Trattoria Mario.
But if you seek a less overwhelming taste of Medieval Italy, try Siena; the ancient walled city known for its differing "contrades" (neighborhoods), each represented by banners and flags featuring 17 symbols from the Oca (goose) and the Tartuca (turtle), to my personal favorite Leocorno (unicorn).
Siena is best explored without an agenda, since it's a fairly small city with winding cobblestoned streets that ultimately lead into the Piazza del Campo, with its 400-step Torre del Mangia, a massive tower built in the 14th century. If you've got the energy, climb to the top for spectacular views of Tuscany.
As is often the case, the cafes and trattorias around the square get very touristy, so get lost among the car-less streets surrounding it. If you're lucky, you'll land at the mysterious-looking Pizzicheria de Miccoli, with its velvet-curtained doorway. Inside, a man who looks straight out of Ratatouille will cut fresh slices of porchetta, prosciutto, and various cheeses for a sandwich. There are no tables and chairs, but it's worth standing and dining on a stack of wine crates at this family-owned shop.
Where to Stay: Try the very elegant Certosa di Maggiano, a 14th century monastery with just nine rooms and eight suites, making it a romantic destination for couples. With vaulted ceilings and beautiful aristocratic decor, you'll feel like royalty at this intimate resort outside the city walls.
Skip San Gimignano, Try Castellina in Chianti
San Gimignano means well. But the walled city plays host to tourists clamoring into wine tasting rooms for a sip of Vernaccia wine before climbing the bell tower before stopping in a leather store, before hopping back on the bus. Think smaller, to Castellina in Chianti. 35 miles south of Florence, you'll get an intimate look at the true charms of Tuscan life.
First, duck under the covered passage known as the Via delle Volte. Along the Medieval walls, you'll find galleries, gelaterias, and shops selling locally made wooden kitchen tools. At the end of the covered tunnel at the edge of town, turn back and walk along the sidewalk on the sunny main drag where you'll find kitschy shops and sidewalk cafes.
If you have a car, drive a quick 20 minutes to Panzano in Chianti to pay a visit to the Dante-quoting butcher, Dario Cecchini, at his classical music-blaring butcher shop: Antica Macelleria Cecchini. You'll find locals seated along the curb just outside enjoying glasses of red wine and small plates of his 'sushi del Chianti' and other treats offered complimentary for newcomers (and regulars).
Where to Stay: Head to the center of town where Palazzo Squarcialupi offers 18 beautiful rooms with wooden-beamed ceilings and frescoed walls. Sunbathing by the pool offers views of rolling green hills and cypress trees. Rates from 120 Euro.
Skip Rome, Try Milan
Rome is so yesterday. Literally, it's ancient. From The Vatican to the Colosseum to the Trevi Fountain, there's lots of looking back here. Sure, areas like Trastevere now offer a glimpse of the modern, young Italian lifestyle, but most people come to Rome to ponder "the way we were."
Despite what you've heard ("it's gray and industrial "), skip Rome in favor of the northern metropolis of Milan, where well-dressed locals commute by rent-a-bike and order spritzes (Aperol, Prosecco, and an orange slice). (It was also one of Fodor's Places to Go in 2012) Of course, Milan offers plenty in the way of history, from da Vinci's The Last Supper at the Santa Maria delle Grazie to the gorgeous Gothic Duomo, but it's best to take advantage of the well-run Metropolitana (subway) to explore beyond the obvious. This is the city of Armani, Prada, and Missoni after all.
Head to the Brera neighborhood to pop into designer stores where you'll discover they offer more than just exquisite (expensive) clothing—most stores have "extras" like cafes and hair salons, not to mention merciful blasts of air conditioning. Anyone with a subscription to Vogue should head to 10 Corso Como, a sanctuary for the high-heeled looking for over-the-top accessories, perfumes, shoes, photography, furniture, books, and of course clothing, in a hyper-designed space (that also has a café).
Being in Italy, Milan has no shortage of great restaurants. Try classic Milanese dishes, like cotoletta alla Milanese (breaded veal cut), with just touch of lemon and a side of arugula at Liu Ristorante. Splurge at Osteria La Bistecca where bowtie-wearing waiters serve super-soft meatballs, creamy spaghetti carbonara, and of course, mouthwatering bistecca.
When the sun goes down, aperitivo heats up. Many restaurants offer meals with the purchase of a drink (think happy hour, but with prosciutto instead of wings.) Head to the Naziglai area to find a host of choices and do yourself a favor: douse yourself in mosquito spray first. As the night wears on, find an outdoor couch at Pacino Cafe, a hip spot that plays everything from house music to Kings of Leon.
Where to Stay: If you want to feel like a local, try Alle Meraviglie, a boutique hotel near the Duomo that offers apartment-like living with super chic amenities. Rates from 175 Euros. Or, splurge at the sleek, luxe Bulgari Milano, where you'll find modern rooms within and manicured gardens that invite locals and guests outside for coffees or aperitivos. Rates from 530 Euro.
Skip Pisa, Try Lucca
So there's this tower that's leaning... and it's been leaning for a while now... Worth seeing? We'd say no. You'll have more pictures of tourists than the tower anyway. Skip over to Lucca instead, where the streets are filled with fewer tourists (or at least fewer obvious ones) and the Tuscan lifestyle is alive and well.
Yes it's another walled city, but this one is mostly pedestrian and isn't as hilly as the others, making it also bike friendly. Lucca's architecture is noteworthy, with the carved stone columns of the Duomo and pastel-colored stucco buildings with terracotta roofs. Add to that the horse-drawn carriages, and the town takes on this magically charming vibe. Opera fans will want to stop and pay respects at the birthplace of Giacomo Puccini, just steps from the center of town.
You'll spot local teens eating pizza off paper plates while sitting on the curbs of cobblestone roads, while older locals opt for a street food specialty known as cecina, or "Tuscan Toast"—flatbread made from chickpeas.
At Caffe Di Simo off the main shopping street of Via Fillungo, enjoy an espresso and ponder the life of Puccini, who was a regular.
Where to Stay: Hotel Ilaria may be slightly removed from the city center, but they offer free bike rental, and seeing as that's the best way to get around Lucca, this modern 36-room hotel (with a hot tub, to boot) is a win-win. Rates from 200 Euro.
Member Comments (13) Post a Comment
This is a very disappointing article. Whether you're a seasoned traveller or a first time visitor, skipping Rome for Milan is ridiculous. I lived in Rome for four months and still felt as if that wasn't enough. There is no place that has as much history and culture as Rome does. Places such as the Pantheon & Colosseum have a rich history and incredible architecture true to its time period. Rome is one of the only cities where much of the structure and materials of buildings is original. I agree the city is definitely overrun with tourists, but there are hidden gems in Rome that you will not find in any other city.
I also disagree that you should skip florence for siena, I visited both and Siena was just as overrun with tourists. Both cities are fabulous in different ways. Siena has a small town feel to it similar to Florence, but the leather market in Florence is exceptional. Even if you have no interest in purchasing leather, the quality, options, and popularity of it is worth a visit. Also visiting italy and missing Ufizi is a shame in itself.
Lastly, Amalfi coast is an expensive, touristy area but well worth the visit during off season. The beauty of the coast is unmatchable to anywhere else. It is very picturesque and relaxing. Limoncello was phenomenal. Cinque terre is definitely comparable, but is has become very touristy as well.
I'm glad I'm no the only one disappointed with the suggestions here. This is our first time traveling to Italy (end of Nov) and every one of the "should skip" places, with the exception of San Gimignano, are on our itinerary! Maybe we're just history buffs but we'd NEVER go to Italy on a 1st trip there and skip these places. As some of you said, maybe for the seasoned traveler these would be good suggestions.
Siena for Florence? Milan for Rome? This is a joke, right?
Both cities are so rich and complex, each time I visit them, I find new joys. I agree with the writer who suggested you travel a bit off season and miss the crowds. If you have the nerves, rent a car and drive from Sorrento to Sicily and back, hitting the small towns like Pizzo and Capo Vaticano, drive out into the countryside, stop at small vineyards, buy some local wines and cheeses and breads, stay at some agriturismos... but skip Rome and Florence? Nevah!
I feel this article was written with the intent of reaching out to those who are very seasoned travelers and have been there and done that, in which this would be some great advice. However I am glad to read all of the feedback, I will be traveling to France and Italy in the beginning of Oct., and though I have been to Europe before this will be my first time in Italy. We will be visiting Venice, Greve, (with a day unplanned to drive surrounding areas) Florence and Rome. From your comments I feel we have made the right decision, one of our main purposes is to see the art and history of Italy. Thanks for the comments, I am very excited to see all that Italy has to offer. I would never tell a first time visitor to the US to skip NYC due to the crowds, for a smaller less traveled place.
I completely agree with most of the comments that have been made. Almost every one of the places this blogger mentions are as overrun with tourists, particularly Cinque Terre and Siena as the places she suggests you avoid. I have visited Italy on more than a dozen separate occasions, for up to six weeks at a time, and have lived in Italy for a year. There are indeed less visited places, such as Arezzo in Tuscany, or Genoa in Liguria, Turin in the north, or pretty towns such as Rapallo along the coast from Cinque Terre, but they should be seen in addition not instead of. Skip Florence and Rome? You'll be missing the heart of Italy! Just pick your time a little better and avoid the crazy months of June, July and September and you'll have a quieter and easier time of it.
You cannot "skip" Rome! Rome is unequaled. Whether you love art, the ancient world, or food. Rome has it all and more. I've been 4 times, the last time for 10 days, and there are still things I want to see and do. Just don't go during the summer or between New Years and Epiphany (January 6).
I heartily endorse the opinions offered in the comments. If you have been to Italy several times and thoroughly enjoyed the amazing beauty, history, and delights of Rome and Florence, then by all means spread into the countryside. But to miss the Uffizi in favor of Siena would be nuts. No comparison at all, and I spent time in Siena last October. We had a lovely visit but it's not close to the experience of Florence. We do a lot of our Italian travel in October and the Amalfi coast is spectacular that time of year, the hotel rates are slightly lower and the bus crowds are almost gone. So definitely adjust your travel times but not your destinations!
To learn more about visiting the Cinque Terre, including all of the latest travel updates and how we are working to rebuild, restore and preserve Vernazza, see www.savevernazza.com. --Ruth Manfredi, President, Save Vernazza (a non-profit organization)
Lucca instead of Pisa, agreed, but your other substitutions - no way. We've visited all these places - our travelogues are posted on our non-commercial web site: TheTravelzine - eating our way through Italy and western Europe since 1996.
I wouldn't call any of these places lesser known haunts or hidden gems. Especially Cinque Terre. Even in October the weekend days in Cinque Terre were shoulder to shoulder people, easily as crowded as Venice. Meanwhile Rome was a breath of fresh air with, yes, lots of people but also lots of -space-. Tour buses found Siena long ago. This article isn't bad, but I wish the intro paragraph hadn't set me up for a disappointment.
I'm thinking you have an aversion to tour-buses and I couldn't agree with you more on that point, they are just unsuited to some of these small tourist towns and winding roads such as on the Amalfi Coast. However I could also not disagree more on several of your choices. You can't just substitute Milan for Rome or Castellina in Chianti instead of San Gimignano. It's like comparing apples and oranges. All these places have their own identity and charm not to mention that these are UNESCO world heritage sites of great historical importance in their own right. If you are a tourist in Italy you would be crazy not to want to see these places so please don't just skip them or you really will be missing something. Please do not get the idea any of these places are overrated with the exception of perhaps Milan which is expensive, the weather can be awful (why do you think they built all those galleria's along the shopping streets) and it is not compact like the historical centre of Rome. If you don't like the crowds change your travel season you may even end up saving a buck or two.
I am the chief editor of Italian Travel Portal called Dolcevia and have been writing about Italy for about 10 years.
I agree with everyone of these, but I wouldn't skip Florence. Too many great art treasures to pass up.
Great blog. Next year when we go to Tuscany will make a trip to Cinque Terre before heading home.
Fodor's Top News & Features
- Cheap and Chic: 10 Affordable Hawaii Hotels
- World's Best Destinations for Solo Travel
- 10 Castles You Can Actually Afford to Sleep In
- 10 Best Lakeside Hotels in the US
- Pot Tourism: How to Buy Marijuana in Colorado
- Where to Eat in San Francisco Now
- 5 Perfect Dublin Itineraries
- Where to Eat in Orlando Now
- 7 Great Food Festivals & Street Fairs on Oahu
- Top 6 Alaskan Cruises for 2014
- 80 Degrees: Fodor's Helps You Find Your Best Beach Vacation Spots
- Fodor's Go List 2014: Where we are going in 2014
- World Cup Fever: Start planning your trip to Brazil!
- Fodor's 100 Hotel Awards: Check out the winners of 2013
- Weekend Getaways: Fodor's Recommends the Best Weekend Escapes in the US
- Great American Vacation: Find Your Next U.S. Trip with Fodor's
- $239 -- 4-Star Grand Cayman Beach Resort, Save 60%The Westin Grand Cayman Seven Mile Beach Resort & Spa
- $299 & up -- Caribbean 7-Night Cruises w/ExtrasNorwegian Cruise Line
- $765 & up -- Big Island 3-Night Vacations w/Air & Car RentalPleasant Holidays
- $1049 & up -- Jamaica: All-Incl. 'Kids Stay Free' Trip w/AirApple Vacations
- $2279* & up -- Worldwide Business Class Fares (R/T w/Tax)ASAP Tickets
- $769 & up -- Cancun: Iberostar Garden Bungalow Escape w/AirApple Vacations