United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

Woodbury Common Saturdays - by car or by bus?

Jump to last reply

Hi everyone,

I plan a short shopping visit to NY at the end of April (weekend prior to 1st of May) and I will also go to Woodbury Common. I've already been there, but my husband did the driving back then and it was on a weekday. This time I'm alone and I can only get there on Saturday.

As I arrive very late on Friday, my first hotel is directly at the airport (JFK). My second hotel is downtown Manhattan, close to the WTC site.

What do you suggest?:

A - Rent a car at the airport on Saturday Morning (how early?), drive directly to WC, shop until the afternoon or so and drive back to Manhattan, where I could leave my bags and case at the hotel (although I remember major traffic problems in the WTC area because of the building site) and then return the car at the city rental station somewhere in Greenwich Village. Is there any major traffic from JFK (via Manhattan?) to Woodbury on a Saturday morning and into Manhattan in the afternoon or evening?. I feel uncomfortable with the idea of driving in NY City. I would certainly take a GPS and try to get back by daylight. I presume that the car is more flexible, can carry my bags, and I don't have to wait for the bus.

Or

B - Take the airtrain or subway into Manhattan Saturday morning (how long does it take from JFK to Port Authority Bus Terminal?), get to WC by Greyline or similar and get back to NY in the afternoon or later. I would have to get from the bus terminal to the hotel by subway, and I have to carry my heavy suitcase - are there any elevators or lifts? I can only remember normal stairs...

Thanks in advance for your answers and suggestions!

26 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Writers Needed for Mexico
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Jul 24, 14 at 12:19 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Orlando-off-the-beaten-track
  2. 2 Have you done an aquarium sleepover?
  3. 3 DC, Philadelphia, New York, Maine, Acadia NP and Niagara Falls in 11 days?
  4. 4 Day Trip OUT of Los Angeles
  5. 5 Roads into Estes Park
  6. 6 Whale watching
  7. 7 New York City Borough Walking: Where for Diverse Flavorful Neighborhoods?
  8. 8 San Antonio suggestions anyone?
  9. 9 Disappointed with Hotwire for our Austin Rental Car
  10. 10 Priceline: bid for walkable to Alamo/Riverwalk in San Antonio. Possible?
  11. 11 Houston in September
  12. 12 Restaurant recommendations for lower east side & upper west side
  13. 13 Stubhub and NFL Tickets
  14. 14 Restaurant recommendations for Washington DC - city centre
  15. 15 Where to add a few days in Colorado?
  16. 16 Studio-size Apartments, Guest Houses for rent, Ojai and Ventura
  17. 17 Trip Report Great Girls' Weekend in NYC!
  18. 18 Road Trip
  19. 19 New York City Restaurants
  20. 20 Best Sonoma Wineries for Group Visit
  21. 21 Itinerary for solo traveler to Maui, Hawaii
  22. 22 San Fran experts: need help with Bay vista points
  23. 23 Hawaii Trip - Maui, Kauai and Honolulu in 9 days
  24. 24 palm desert, CA
  25. 25 New York Trip
View next 25 » Back to the top