United States Forums

Start a new topic Change Forum
Advanced search

flying with carry-on vs checked bags

Jump to last reply

What's the general consensus here on whether to just do carry-on bags or to check some? We have always just done carry-on (even before airlines started charging) to speed things up getting out of the airport and so we wouldn't have any lost bags.

For our upcoming trip we're considering checking a bag or two but we're completely torn. It's a 17 day trip and it would be sooo nice to have an extra bag with a few comforts of home... favorite coffee, Hot Shot machine (instant hot water for tea, oatmeal, etc) enough clothes/boots to keep me warm, umbrella, and we could go ahead and pre-purchase a lot of the things we would have to buy there (toiletries, picnic stuff, etc) .

It's $50 to check one bag round trip, so we're considering upgrading our American Express card to the next level for $40 so all 4 of us would actually be able to check a bag for "free" (plus we'd get 10,000 bonus FF miles).

Our big concern is LOST baggage. We would still carry-on the valuables and things we couldn't do without. Our other concerns are lugging around the extra luggage and having to wait for it rather than a quick airport exit.

Checking bags also has advantages beyond being able to take extra things. For once it would be so nice for us not to have 8 bags that the 4 of us need to go through security with and then on the plane quickly stow and get out of the way.

Just looking for a push one way or the other!

59 Replies |Back to top

| Add a Reply

Sign in to comment.

Recent Activity

  • Announcement:
  • Fodor's Go List 2015 Has Been Announced
    by Emily_D Fodor's Editor | Posted on Dec 19, 14 at 05:08 PM
View all United States activity »
  1. 1 Family Reunion Ideas for Maine Coast
  2. 2 3 weeks in USA in February -- final post before booking hotels
  3. 3 Seattle hotel recommendation needed
  4. 4 advice on possible employment in GA or NC rural areas
  5. 5 Zion, Bryce, Page, GC South Rim, and Arches
  6. 6 Tipping advice
  7. 7 Christmas weather?
  8. 8 Big island itinerary
  9. 9 New York City and New England
  10. 10 Need help planning weekend trips: Georgia, Chicago, Tennessee, Alaska?!
  11. 11 NYT article on exploring Los Angeles without a car
  12. 12 Trip Report San Diego Girl's Trip in December
  13. 13 Flying from LA to Massachusetts
  14. 14 Utah-Arizona National Parks intinary help needed
  15. 15 Grand Tetons, Yellowstone and Banff in May or early Sept.?
  16. 16 Thousand Islands
  17. 17 Best Destination in USA
  18. 18 Please help identify location in Southern California
  19. 19 August 2015 Western Roadtrip Route? 30 days...Two 22-year-old Girls
  20. 20 Nashville - Weekend Trip
  21. 21 WHY are rental cars in December in Florida so expensive?
  22. 22 Better cooking store in Seattle
  23. 23 Trip Report 62 Hikers airlifted out of Kalalau Trail
  24. 24 Grand Teton Romantic Accomdations
  25. 25 Trip Report The East Coast adventure: December 2014
View next 25 » Back to the top