10 Best Restaurants in Pennsylvania Dutch Country, Pennsylvania

Background Illustration for Restaurants

Like the German cuisine that influenced it, Pennsylvania Dutch cooking is hearty and uses ingredients from local farms. Though their numbers are dwindling, there are still a few traditional Pennsylvania Dutch restaurants where you can dine family style. Lancaster County has numerous reasonably priced family restaurants, along with a number of eateries offering more exotic fare. The cuisine is changing and expanding to include many flavors beyond traditional Amish. Unless otherwise noted, liquor is served.

John Wright Restaurant

$$ Fodor's Choice

At this waterfront spot in historic Wrightsville, across the Susquehanna River from Columbia, you can enjoy a breathtaking view of the river while seated outdoors eating wood-fired pizzas topped with ingredients grown on-site. The popular bar and restaurant (reservations strongly suggested) also has a glass-walled dining room to take in the scenery year-round. Several menus are offered, from lunch (cream of crab soup) and dinner (house sausage platter) to a mammoth fixed-price Sunday brunch buffet complete with a prime rib carving station, omelets made to order, and a make-your-own Bloody Mary bar. Look for weekly dinner specials and seasonally inspired favorites.

Bulls Head Public House

$$

Take a table in the tavern-like dining room or a stool at the bar for a menu of English and American classics. Welsh rarebit, fish-and-chips, or chicken-and-leek pie will power you up for an afternoon of shopping or an evening of trivia competition, or you can stick with the burger and a cask ale. There's outdoor seating in warm weather.

The Exchange

$$

Perched atop the Marriott at Penn Square, this chic lounge and restaurant (for those 21 and over) has the best views in town from its floor-to-ceiling windows and stylish deck. Enjoy a cocktail and the globally inspired small plates, from Lebanon bologna sliders to crispy halloumi cheese, and a rotating selection of wood-fired pizzas while enjoying the view.

25 S. Queen St., Lancaster, PA, 17603, USA
717-207–4096
Known For
  • Great sunset viewing
  • Weekday happy hour food and drink specials
  • Crowd is 21 and over only

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Fireside Tavern

$$

With friendly service and tasty food, it's no wonder Fireside Tavern is a huge locals' favorite. The surf-and-turf burger or shepherd's pie will fill you up after a day of sightseeing, and adults might enjoy the busy bar. From some of the indoor tables and the outdoor deck, there are gorgeous views of farmland.

1500 Historic Dr., Strasburg, PA, 17579, USA
717-687–7979
Known For
  • Reservations recommended
  • Crab cakes
  • Large selection of tap beer
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun. and Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?

Garryowen Irish Pub

$$

A favorite with locals, this pub serves authentic Irish dishes made from the owner's family recipes, importing some of their ingredients direct from Ireland. The kitchen also sends out American pub favorites like wings and burgers and more than 100 Irish whiskies and 15 draft beers quench thirsts. Irish sesiuns (open Celtic music jams) take place twice a month and live music plays every Friday and Saturday night.

126 Chambersburg St., Gettysburg, PA, 17325, USA
717-337–2719
Known For
  • Large outdoor space
  • Perfectly poured Guinness
  • Ulster Fry (sausages, egg, grilled tomato, and Irish soda bread), white pudding (pork and oatmeal), black pudding (pig's blood added),

Something incorrect in this review?

Himalayan Curry and Grill

$$

This family-owned Nepalese and Indian restaurant is a longtime favorite in downtown Lancaster, serving up popular Indian specialties like tandoori and chana masala (a chickpea-based curry), as well as Nepalese dry curries and steamed dumplings. The cozy dining room quickly gets packed on weekend nights and weekday lunch hours (there's an all-you-can-eat lunch buffet Monday through Saturday in addition to the regular menu), but the staff gracefully handles the constant flow. There's also an all-you-can-eat dinner buffet on Monday night, and although there is no alcohol on the menu, the restaurant has a BYOB policy.

22 E. Orange St., Lancaster, PA, 17601, USA
717-393–2330
Known For
  • Dal palak (a spinach-and-lentil curry)
  • Spicy vindaloo dishes
  • Momo (Nepalese dumplings filled with vegetables or chicken)
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Kling House

$$

This former home in Kitchen Kettle Village is a couple of notches above the other options in Intercourse and Bird-in-Hand. Lunch off the seasonal menu might include a chicken salad sandwich or boeuf bourguignon; the complimentary appetizer of crackers with cream cheese and red-pepper jam is tasty. Shoofly pie is a treat for dessert, but don't miss the brown butter cookies. Try to get one of the tables on the sunny enclosed porch.

McCleary's Pub

$$

A lively pub up front and a dining room and enclosed patio in back, McCleary's serves up satisfying dishes such as crab cakes and pub steaks. There's a long list of Irish and American brews, and live music Wednesday through Saturday.

130 Front St., Marietta, PA, 17547, USA
717-426–2225
Known For
  • Irish specialties
  • Crab cakes
  • Neighborhood feel
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?

Southern Market

$$

A few blocks from Central Market, this one-time farmers' market built in 1888 has been repurposed as a food hall. Whether you're in the mood for sushi or bratwurst or just a cup of coffee, you'll find a wide variety of global cuisines at the 12 stands. Order at the stations of your choice and bring your food out to one of the tables or the central bar. A pizza place operates off one end of the hall.

100 S. Queen St., Lancaster, PA, 17603, USA
717-517–3000
Known For
  • Across the street from the convention center
  • Round bar at the center of the hall serves craft cocktails and beer
  • Expansive, airy space never seems to get crowded
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. and Tues.

Something incorrect in this review?

Tröegs Independent Brewing

$$

It's possible you might need a break from chocolate, and if you do, you can rest assured that the Tröegs brewery will be the perfect antidote, with its creative menus and multiple draft beers (some you can only get here) available in 4oz., 10oz., and 16oz. sizes. Menu options, which sell out fast, include starters like the pickle plate and tabbouleh salad and mains like fluke crudo, crab lasagna rotolo, red lentil daal, and the meatloaf sandwich---yes, at a brewery. 

200 East Hershey Park Dr., Hershey, PA, 17033, USA
717-534--1297
Known For
  • Inventive menu options including kids' options and Sunday brunch specials
  • Hour-long guided brewery tours
  • Beer, beer, and beer

Something incorrect in this review?