3 Best Hotels in Blue Hill Peninsula and Deer Isle, Maine

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Blue Hill Peninsula and Deer Isle - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Aragosta

$$$ | 300 Goose Cove Rd., Deer Isle, ME, USA Fodor's Choice

Nestled among spruces, moss-covered rocks, and the Barred Island Nature Preserve, Aragosta is one of Maine's most tranquil oceanfront complexes. The property includes nine private cottages with kitchenettes and sitting areas that sleep up to four guests as well as three semidetached suites, a private beach, and one of the most acclaimed restaurants in the state.

Pros

  • Cottages are dog-friendly
  • Postcard-perfect location
  • Excellent on-site restaurant

Cons

  • A car is a must
  • Suites are not dog-friendly
  • Wi-Fi is only available in the restaurant
300 Goose Cove Rd., Deer Isle, ME, USA
207-348–6900
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Oct.–mid-May
9 cottages, 3 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

The Oakland House Seaside Resort

$$ | 435 Herrick Rd., Brooksville, ME, 04617, USA

The coastal acreage on which the main inn, with its recently renovated rooms, and cottages are set was an original land grant by Great Britain’s King George III in 1767 to John and Hannah Billings, direct ascendants of the current innkeepers, Rick and Robin Littlefield. The property has been a working farm, a quarry, an ice business, and, for the past 130 years, a gracious summer colony boasting old-fashioned Maine hospitality. There are private beaches, access to hiking trails, and on-site kayak rentals. 

Pros

  • Old-fashioned Maine hospitality
  • Private beaches
  • Lots of outdoor activity options

Cons

  • No on-site restaurant
  • Might feel too isolated for some
  • Do-it-yourself housekeeping
435 Herrick Rd., Brooksville, ME, 04617, USA
207-359–8521
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Oct.–early Mar.
21 units
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Under Canvas Acadia

$$$$ | 702 Surry Rd., Surry, ME, 04684, USA

Amid 100 acres on Union River Bay, this glamping property has luxury tents with king-size beds, bathrooms, organic toiletries, wood stoves, and other creature comforts. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast and dinner featuring local eggs, seafood, meat, cheeses and vegetables, as well as fresh bread and pastries, locally roasted coffee, Maine beer, and craft cocktails. There is morning yoga, evening live music, and kids' activities throughout the day. Comfortable outdoor seating surrounds huge firepits where guests can make complimentary s’mores. Ample staff is available to help transport things to your tent, arrange day trips in the area, and supply any gear you might have forgotten. Quiet time begins at 10 pm nightly.

Pros

  • Lots of on-site amenities and activities
  • Breathtaking coast and Cadillac Mountain views
  • Good base for Acadia National Park visits

Cons

  • It still feels like camping
  • Pricey rates and food and activities cost extra
  • Some might find 10 pm quiet time restricting
702 Surry Rd., Surry, ME, 04684, USA
888-496–1148
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Oct.–mid-May
63 tents
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video