86 Best Hotels in Sicily, Italy

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Sicily - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Bohémien Boutique Guesthouse

$ | Via Umberto I 15C, Cefalù, 90015, Italy

The fanciest, contemporary-design-led B&B in town offers top-of-the-line showers, striking lighting, and sumptuous beds in a converted family apartment building from the 19th century.

Pros

  • Free hot drinks and water in the cozy guest lounge
  • Lovely owner Mari
  • Decadent freestanding bath in two rooms

Cons

  • Self check-in and lack of 24/7 reception
  • Underwhelming breakfast at nearby Golden Bar
  • No elevator
Via Umberto I 15C, Cefalù, 90015, Italy
331-7583397
Hotel Details
5 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Casa Vacanze Santa Lucia

$ | Corso Umberto I, Caccamo, 90012, Italy

While these accommodations may be too basic for some visitors, this homey apartment with terrace views near the castle is well maintained and perfectly positioned to explore the town. Breakfast is served at a local bar, and the handy kitchenette is ideal for putting together meals using the local produce. 

Pros

  • Beautiful location
  • Kitchenette for preparing meals
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • Difficult to find
  • Very small
  • Access via stairs only
Corso Umberto I, Caccamo, 90012, Italy
380-3484661
Hotel Details
1 apartment
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Casale Drinzi

$ | Contrada Drinz, Collesano, 90016, Italy

Located a little bit outside of Collesano, this old converted farmhouse offers visitors a farm stay experience with basic, bargain-rate rooms and a restaurant serving hearty Madonie mountain fare. 

Pros

  • Very affordable prices
  • Excellent restaurant and pizzeria
  • Beautiful location

Cons

  • Service can be a little brusque
  • Rustic farm stay not for everyone
  • Online booking only
Contrada Drinz, Collesano, 90016, Italy
0921-664027
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Casetta di Rosina

$ | 22 Piazza Zafferana, Caccamo, 90012, Italy

These two apartments are located within an elegantly modern restored home in the center of town with all the comforts and facilities needed, including a kitchen, coffee machine, free Wi-Fi, and sofa beds for extra occupants.

Pros

  • Good location
  • Unfussy modern decor
  • Options for families and groups

Cons

  • No elevator
  • Difficult to find
  • On the small side
22 Piazza Zafferana, Caccamo, 90012, Italy
338-9243831
Hotel Details
2 apartments
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Eremo della Giubiliana

$ | Contrada Giubiliana, Ragusa, 97100, Italy

In the countryside about 20 minutes by car south of Ragusa, this charming family-run monastery-turned-hotel features friendly service and a relaxed but luxurious vibe, with unique rooms in former monks' chambers that vary in size and lay-out but are all quiet and well-appointed. All of them come with antiques, stone floors, wood-beamed ceilings, and tapestries; some also have fireplaces, whirlpools, and/or balconies. The restaurant offers a selection of Sicilian standards, and there's a lovely patio, where guests can enjoy the expansive breakfast buffet.

Pros

  • Peaceful atmosphere
  • Rooms filled with character
  • Top-notch service

Cons

  • Grounds, while lovely, could use better upkeep
  • Restaurant food could be better
  • No other nearby eateries due to remote location
Contrada Giubiliana, Ragusa, 97100, Italy
0932-669119
Hotel Details
24 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Grand Hotel Baia Verde

$ | Via Angelo Musco 8, Aci Castello, 95021, Italy

This large property, rising above the lava rocks, right on the sea feels a bit like a time capsule. You can easily imagine the Rat Pack making it their home on a Sicilian holiday. For some, that means the property is stuck in the past and could use a reboot, but for others, it's the perfect amount of old-school panache.

Pros

  • Pool and private sea access
  • Sea views from many rooms
  • Full spa and wellness center

Cons

  • Service can be erratic
  • Smaller rooms tend to be dark
  • Needs considerable updating
Via Angelo Musco 8, Aci Castello, 95021, Italy
095-491522
Hotel Details
147 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Grand Hotel Faraglione

$ | Via Lungomare dei Ciclopi, 115, Aci Trezza, 95021, Italy

This contemporary, light-filled hotel makes the most of its position right in front of the sea and the faraglioni. Indulge in a cocktail on the terrace at sunset, ponder over which Sicilian specialty to order in the attached restaurant, or spend some time at the nearby beach club. Whatever you do, it will be met with impeccable and amicable service. 

Pros

  • The sea at your door
  • Nothing too much trouble for the staff
  • Ample buffet breakfast

Cons

  • Limited rooms with sea view
  • Parking costs extra
  • Can be a bit noisy
Via Lungomare dei Ciclopi, 115, Aci Trezza, 95021, Italy
095-277463
Hotel Details
50 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Grand Hotel Piazza Borsa

$ | Via dei Cartari 18, Palermo, 90133, Italy

Cleverly converted from three historic buildings—a bank, a palazzo, and a monastery—this hotel with modern, unadorned rooms is ideally located just off the central axis of Via Vittorio Emanuele. It's an elegant complex, featuring vaulted ceilings and an expansive, airy courtyard lobby with a retractable roof awning that's open in warm weather, plus a beautifully designed restaurant. 

Pros

  • Quiet but central location
  • Beguiling architecture and courtyard
  • Wellness center with fitness equipment, rare for Sicily hotels

Cons

  • Most rooms have showers in the bathtubs
  • Staff sometimes inattentive
  • Limited parking
Via dei Cartari 18, Palermo, 90133, Italy
091-320075
Hotel Details
127 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Grand Hotel Villa Politi

$ | Via M. Politi 2, Siracusa, 96100, Italy

Winston Churchill, European royalty, and other VIPs have frequented the grand 18th-century Villa Politi, and although it's now a little faded, it retains a sense of elegance with rococo furnishings alongside basic modern luxuries like comfy beds. Set back from the road, the hotel is in the extensive gardens of the Latomie dei Cappuccini, overlooking a small archaeological site. Some rooms have balconies, private terraces, and partial sea views, others have far less salubrious views (be sure to check).

Pros

  • Handy for the Neapolis archaeological site
  • Free parking in the hotel lot
  • Expansive outdoor pool and nearby private beach

Cons

  • A fair distance from the sights of Ortigia
  • Not many restaurants in the neighborhood
  • Not as sparkling and fresh as in the past
Via M. Politi 2, Siracusa, 96100, Italy
0931-412121
Hotel Details
100 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Heart of Sicily

$ | Strada Santa Caterina 63, 98073, Italy

This rental apartment near the center of Mistretta allows you to stay directly in the old town, with basic but reasonably priced rooms and wonderful views from the terrace. 

Pros

  • Close to local cafés and sights
  • Abundant breakfast
  • Fab views

Cons

  • A little hard to find
  • Small bathrooms
  • Many stairs
Strada Santa Caterina 63, 98073, Italy
339-2106377
Hotel Details
1 apartment
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Aegusa

$ | Via Garibaldi 11, Favigana, 91023, Italy

This attractive midrange hotel in the center of Favignana town is in an old palazzo but has modern furnishings and fittings. Most of the guest rooms are spacious; some even have balconies, but all are impeccably clean with comfortable beds, including those located in a nearby annex (which may be a better choice for those who prefer more privacy). There's a good restaurant in an internal courtyard garden, where breakfast is also served. Stays in summer must be for a minimum of four or five nights.

Pros

  • Nice restaurant
  • Central location
  • Spacious rooms

Cons

  • Front-facing rooms can get street noise
  • Longer stays only
  • Disappointing breakfast
Via Garibaldi 11, Favigana, 91023, Italy
0923-921739
Hotel Details
Closed Oct.–mid-Apr.
28 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Al Madarig

$ | Largo Petrolo 7, Castellammare del Golfo, 91014, Italy

Spread along one side of the wide expanse of Largo Petrolo, this smart, two-story hotel has warm colors and a welcoming, intimate atmosphere. The reception area has polished parquet floors, modern art on the walls, and a solidly old-fashioned tone. Pay a little extra for one of the best rooms, which are spacious and have balconies overlooking the square. Buffet breakfasts are varied, and you can choose to sit at one of the tables on the piazza. It's an easy walk to restaurants (the harborfront is a 10-minute walk), and guests can make use of a free hotel buggy to a nearby beach.

Pros

  • Free beach shuttle service
  • Convenient location
  • Obliging, multilingual staff

Cons

  • Some rooms are small
  • Very limited parking
  • Slightly dated in parts
Largo Petrolo 7, Castellammare del Golfo, 91014, Italy
0924-33533
Hotel Details
Closed Nov.–Jan.
33 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Aliai

$ | Via Gaie di Garaffe 60, Sciacca, 92019, Italy

Right by the port, the small and modern Hotel Aliai is Sciacca's best choice for anyone wishing to lodge in the lower town. Book one of the three rooms on the top floor; all have harbor views and their own terraces, though guests may have to stoop to avoid the low eaves in the attached bathrooms. Staff are friendly, parking is easy, and breakfast choices include freshly squeezed fruit juice and local pastries. Piazza Scandaliato can be reached in 10 minutes via steps.

Pros

  • Friendly staff
  • Easy parking
  • Good position for the port

Cons

  • Needs refurbishment
  • Three stories and no elevator
  • Low ceilings in top-floor bathrooms
Via Gaie di Garaffe 60, Sciacca, 92019, Italy
349-0507942
Hotel Details
15 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Cala Marina

$ | Don Leonardo Zangara 1, Castellammare del Golfo, 91014, Italy

On the edge of town, overlooking a small beach at the western end of the harbor, this small and chic hotel stands a little apart from the quayside activity, and is all the better for it. The harborfront bars and restaurants are seconds away, yet peace and quiet reign here. The three rooms with balconies at the front are the best choices as other rooms on the side have balconies and partial sea views but face hilly scenery frontwards. The waterfront terrace is a great spot for breakfast, for whiling away an afternoon, or for an evening aperitivo. In summer, a free shuttle service to a nearby beach is available.

Pros

  • Great seafront position close to the action but still quiet
  • Pleasant terrace for breakfast and drinks
  • Beach transfers available

Cons

  • Poor soundproofing in some rooms
  • Only three harborfront rooms
  • Most rooms are on the small side
Don Leonardo Zangara 1, Castellammare del Golfo, 91014, Italy
0924-531841
Hotel Details
15 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Elimo

$ | Via Vittorio Emanuele 75, Erice, 91016, Italy

Like the town of Erice itself, the Hotel Elimo is old-fashioned and yet full of charm; eccentric knickknacks and artwork fill the lobby, and the homey guest rooms are all different, many boasting terraces with views of either the cobblestone streets or the valleys below (when they're not shrouded by clouds). The hotel is ideally located on Erice's main street, convenient to shopping and restaurants, though you may very well opt to dine at the hotel's own eatery, which uses fresh local ingredients and offers superb views. The friendly staff can help recommend which local attractions are worth your while.

Pros

  • Amiable owners and staff
  • Lots of character
  • Great on-site restaurant

Cons

  • Dated in parts
  • Small bathrooms
  • Noise in some rooms
Via Vittorio Emanuele 75, Erice, 91016, Italy
0923-869377
Hotel Details
Closed Jan. and Feb.
21 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Il Gabbiano

$ | Via Liberta 221, 90018, Italy

The location near the railway and a gas station may not entice, but Termini's most comfortable, well-run hotel has spacious, modern rooms and the decent AmeTerra restaurant. 

Pros

  • Close to the beach
  • Good on-site restaurant
  • Free private parking

Cons

  • No elevator
  • Basic businesslike rooms
  • Some rooms a little dark
Via Liberta 221, 90018, Italy
091-8113262
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel La Bussola

$ | Via Nino Bixio 11/13, Milazzo, 98057, Italy

For a convenient, short stay near the port, this sleek, modern hotel offers comfortable rooms, a lounge bar, a bistro restaurant, and a lovely roof garden. It's a reliable option.

Pros

  • Excellent for Aeolian Island ferries
  • Helpful staff
  • Relaxing roof terrace

Cons

  • Maybe too businesslike for some
  • Not near the beach
  • Limited breakfast choices
Via Nino Bixio 11/13, Milazzo, 98057, Italy
090-9221244
Hotel Details
26 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel La Sciara

$ | Via Barnao, Stromboli, 98050, Italy

There's nothing much more dramatic than lying poolside here, with views of the sea in one direction and a prime view of the volcano in the other. This hotel got a facelift in 2018 and has comfortable but simple rooms. It's known as a very reliable option on an island where dependable lodging isn't always easy to find.

Pros

  • Welcoming environment at base of the volcano
  • Good in-house restaurant
  • Large pool

Cons

  • A bit old-fashioned
  • Very simple for a luxury property
  • Uncomfortable pool loungers
Via Barnao, Stromboli, 98050, Italy
090-9488000
Hotel Details
Closed Nov.–Mar.
61 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Messenion

$ | Via Francesco Faranda 7, Messina, 98123, Italy

This independent hotel provides tidy accommodations in the style you might expect in a chain aimed at business travelers, but the name and ambience of the hotel are much more connected to the town's local spirit. It's thanks to Anassila, the tyrant who ruled Reggio, that Messina got its name sometime around 491 BC, in honor of his homeland (Messenia) in Greece. And he was given the right to mint money, coins called Messenion, which were vital to the growth of trade in the area. 

Pros

  • Balconies in half the rooms
  • Clean and spacious rooms
  • Good location for exploring Messina by foot

Cons

  • Paid parking
  • More of a business hotel feel
  • Small showers
Via Francesco Faranda 7, Messina, 98123, Italy
090-712674
Hotel Details
18 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Paradiso delle Madonie

$ | Via Dante Alighieri 82, 90013, Italy

This small hotel below the old town, run by the amiable and ever-helpful Massimo and family, has simply furnished modern rooms, making it a good base to explore the surrounding Madonie Mountains. 

Pros

  • Excellent breakfast buffet including Fiasconaro pastries
  • Reasonably priced
  • Wonderful, informative hosts

Cons

  • Very basic, businesslike rooms
  • Located on a quite busy road
  • Furniture and decor dated
Via Dante Alighieri 82, 90013, Italy
0921-994617
Hotel Details
16 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Principe di Villafranca

$ | Via G. Turrisi Colonna 4, Palermo, 90139, Italy

Contemporary art mixed with antique furnishings, creamy marble floors, and vaulted ceilings evoke a luxurious private home in a residential area near Palermo's glitzy shopping district. It's easy to get comfortable in the understated surroundings; relax in the library with an aperitif, or have a workout in the fitness room. Rooms are simple yet elegant, with fine linens, soothing neutral colors, and more modern art.

Pros

  • Clean, modern design
  • Appealing public spaces
  • Quiet, center-adjacent location

Cons

  • Some rooms and bathrooms on the small side
  • Car park has limited spaces
  • Immediate surroundings lack charm
Via G. Turrisi Colonna 4, Palermo, 90139, Italy
091-6118523
Hotel Details
32 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel San Michele

$ | Via San Michele 16, Trapani, 91100, Italy

It's a revelation to find this smart boutique hotel, a former convent, buried within Trapani's rather neglected former Jewish neighborhood close to the port. Once within its doors, though, you'll find everything clean, calm, and orderly, with soothing colors, contemporary furnishings, and bathrooms with spacious walk-in showers. Breakfast, which is an optional extra, is served in the courtyard and includes fresh fruit and croissants with honey. The reception staff is quick to recommend and book a spot for your evening meal, and can arrange to have your vehicle parked in a secure garage and delivered when needed.

Pros

  • Convenient for the hydrofoil dock
  • Valet parking
  • Helpful staff

Cons

  • Breakfast not included in rates
  • Some rooms are cramped
  • A little difficult to find
Via San Michele 16, Trapani, 91100, Italy
0923-23470
Hotel Details
Closed early Jan.–Feb.
21 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Villa Greta

$ | Via Leonardo Da Vinci 46, Taormina, 98039, Italy

Just a few steps down from the luxurious Villa Ducale Hotel—but several degrees more affordable—this cozy, family-run villa sits on the hillside, removed from the action of Taormina. The spacious guest rooms all have balconies from which to admire the looming profile of Etna and the sparkling waters of the Ionian Sea. Breakfast is taken in the glass-fronted restaurant overlooking the terraces of a lushly planted garden; along with the bar, it forms the social hub of the hotel.

Pros

  • Panoramic terrace
  • Environmentally aware
  • Bus stop at the entrance

Cons

  • Lots of steps
  • No elevator
  • Four-night minimum stay June–September
Via Leonardo Da Vinci 46, Taormina, 98039, Italy
0942-28286
Hotel Details
Closed late Nov.–late Dec.
12 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel Villa Morgana

$ | Via Consolare Pompea 1965, Messina, 98165, Italy

This tranquil villa from the 1970s is perched at the edge of the Ganzirri Lake and looks out over shady gardens, sunny terraces, and a secluded infinity pool. Guest rooms are not shy of color and are just a few steps away from spa treatments and a gym. From here, it's an easy walk around the lake or to the beaches of Capo Peloro.

Pros

  • Tranquil location
  • Beautiful pool
  • Extensive garden

Cons

  • Minimum two- to four-night stay in summer
  • No sea views
  • You'll need a car
Via Consolare Pompea 1965, Messina, 98165, Italy
090-325575
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Nov.–Mar.
15 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Il Giardino dei Carubi

$ | Via XXIV Maggio, Alicudi, Italy

Flooded with light and kissed by the island's winds, this bright and airy B&B brings stylish comfort to the harsh Alicudi terrain. Breezy fabrics in classic white and blue soften the stone dwelling that perches high above the sea. Lounge on the two water-facing terraces (one of which is shaded from the unforgiving sun) for panoramic views and unparalleled star-filled nights.

Pros

  • Accommodating host
  • Wondrously silent
  • Abundant breakfasts

Cons

  • Two-night minimum
  • Limited availability in peak season
  • Getting here can be challenging with luggage but transport by donkey is available
Via XXIV Maggio, Alicudi, Italy
380-7836666
Hotel Details
Closed Oct.–mid-May
4 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Canna

$ | Via Rosa 43, Filicudi Porto, 98050, Italy

A tiny paradise perched on a cliff overlooking the port of Filicudi, the small hotel is family owned and operated (since 1972) by brother Vincenzo and sister Grazia (also the hotel restaurant’s chef) and their father Pietro, who still tends to their vegetable garden, La Canna is a true hidden gem with a family feel, an approach to hospitality that is friendly and laid-back, much like the overall ambience here, as well as the most breathtaking views of the sea and the Eolie. 

Pros

  • Relaxing pool and lounge area
  • Family-friendly atmosphere but equally great for singles and couples
  • Magnificent views

Cons

  • An uphill climb from the port
  • Half-board required in peak season
  • Spotty Wi-Fi
Via Rosa 43, Filicudi Porto, 98050, Italy
090-9889956
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Oct.–mid-Apr.
14 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Dimora del Genio

$ | Via Garibaldi 58, Palermo, 90133, Italy

Stepping into this charming apartment off Piazza della Rivoluzione is like entering a different time zone: a taste of Old Palermo where the elegant furnishings evoke a romantic world you might think only exists today in novels. Crystal chandeliers, rococo mirrors, painted and coffered ceilings, oriental rugs on parquet or majolica floors, and doilies on polished oak tables all create a warm ambience you'll find difficult to leave. It's not all Old World—the owner has stamped her own taste on the decor by adding striking works of 20th-century art. It's in a lively neighborhood, with plenty of bars and restaurants in the vicinity. Extensive breakfasts cost €12–15 extra per person. A self-catering option is also possible for longer stays.

Pros

  • Lively neighborhood
  • Spacious rooms
  • Antique character

Cons

  • Decor can be a bit somber
  • Lots of steps and no elevator
  • Only two rooms that book up quickly
Via Garibaldi 58, Palermo, 90133, Italy
347-6587664
Hotel Details
2 apartments
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Locando di Postino

$ | Via Picone 10, Salina, Italy

In a converted 150-year-old farmhouse that once housed local priests, this really special boutique hotel in Pollara is a family affair, run by husband and wife Mauro and Amelia (and their children Mariachiara and Francesco). Since they originally renovated and opened the property in 1994 to the present-day, the family is still wholly in charge, respecting nature and their surrounding land and promoting environmental sustainability at every turn. Even the structure is Ecolabel-certified by the EU. With little touches from the past, the rustic-chic rooms are decorated in Aeolian style, each with its own personal patio and hammock, making this place all the more special. 

Pros

  • Eco-certified hotel
  • Private patio and hammock with every room
  • Restaurant on-site

Cons

  • Not so centrally located within Salina and far from all of the ports
  • A car or scooter is necessary if you want to explore other parts of the island
  • Restaurant is open to the public
Via Picone 10, Salina, Italy
090-9843958
Hotel Details
Closed Nov.–Apr.
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Scaletta di Pietra

$ | Piazza San Michele 9, Petralia Soprana, 90026, Italy

Located in the center of Petralia Soprana, a stunning, castle-esque house has been converted into a B&B with modern, comfortable rooms and welcoming hosts.

Pros

  • Stunning views from balconies
  • Delicious breakfast with local products
  • Unique building

Cons

  • A lot of stairs to navigate
  • Steep incline into rooms
  • Rooms may be too small and modest for some
Piazza San Michele 9, Petralia Soprana, 90026, Italy
328-5404500
Hotel Details
5 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

La Tartaruga

$ | Via Carlo Cavasino 4, Marettimo, 91010, Italy

There's nothing remote or rough-and-ready about this gorgeous bed-and-breakfast in the higher part of Marettimo, where tasteful modern design combines with personable hosts to create the perfect island getaway. You may find it difficult to tear yourself away from the sun-drenched roof terrace, equipped with sunbeds and shade sails, from which village and sea spread serenely before you—and it's perfect for star-gazing, too. The four air-conditioned rooms are spacious, airy, and immaculately clean, with rain showers in the en suite bathrooms. Breakfasts include bread straight from the oven, as well as delicious home-baked cakes, tarts, biscuits, and fresh fruit.

Pros

  • Helpful hosts
  • Panoramic roof terrace
  • Brilliant breakfasts

Cons

  • Lacks much privacy
  • No TVs in rooms
  • Availability may be limited
Via Carlo Cavasino 4, Marettimo, 91010, Italy
329-4116346
Hotel Details
Closed Nov.–Mar.
4 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?