5 Best Restaurants in Bermuda

Background Illustration for Restaurants

What's incredible about the Bermuda restaurant scene isn't so much the number or quality of restaurants, but the sheer variety of cuisines represented on the menus, especially considering that Bermuda is such a tiny island. It hosts a medley of global cuisines—British, French, Italian, Portuguese, American, Caribbean, Indian, Chinese, and Thai—palatable reminders of Bermuda's history as a colony.

Many superior independent and resort restaurants attract a constant and steady stream of internationally acclaimed chefs, assuring that the latest techniques and trends are menu regulars. At the same time, virtually all restaurant menus list traditional Bermudian dishes and drinks, so you have the opportunity to taste local specialties at almost any meal.

As you might expect, methods are not all that's imported. Roughly 80% of Bermuda's food is flown or shipped in, most of it from the United States. This explains why restaurant prices are often higher here than on the mainland.

Nevertheless, there are a number of delicious local ingredients that you should look for. At the top of the list is extraordinary seafood, like lobster (best during September through March), crab, oysters, mussels, clams, red snapper, rockfish, tuna, and wahoo. Additionally, many chefs work with local growers to serve fresh seasonal fruits and vegetables, such as potatoes, carrots, leeks, tomatoes, corn, broccoli, and Bermuda onions (one of the island's earliest exports); and in the fruit department, strawberries, cherries, bananas, and loquats (small yellow fruit used for preserves). Imports notwithstanding, Bermudian cuisine really begins and ends with local ingredients and traditional preparations, and therein lies the island's culinary identity.

While in Bermuda, try to eat like a local and put a couple of traditional dishes to the test. Bermuda is a seafood lover’s paradise, with favorite dishes including mussel pie, shark hash, and codfish and bananas. As for soups, you can go for fish chowder, conch chowder, or traditional Portuguese black-eyed bean soup. Don’t forget to kick back and relax after your meal with a rum swizzle, a Black and Coke, or a Dark ’n' Stormy. Ginger beer—which is quite different from ginger ale—remains the island’s most popular soda for the kids.

La Trattoria

$$ Fodor's Choice

Year after year, this long-standing Hamilton eatery has remained a family favorite, with good reason. The yellow and brick interior is warm and inviting, and the waiters are always friendly. Without a doubt the king of the menu is pizza—La Trattoria's pies are fired in a brick, wood-burning 600°F pizza oven. Opt for a traditional margherita, the savory Arugula (with spicy arugula, salty prosciutto, and mozzarella), or even splurge on the Gold Pizza, which has edible gold flakes. Or you can create your own pie from a list of over 20 inventive toppings. If you're not feeling pizza, there's also a variety of pasta options and seafood dishes. If you order the house wine, ask for it to be served in one of their signature ceramic chicken pitchers. This spot is usually packed with locals, both at dinnertime and during the workday lunch rush, so it's best to reserve ahead.

23 Washington La., Hamilton, HM 11, Bermuda
441-295–1877
Known For
  • Reservations needed for lunch and dinner
  • Friendly waitstaff
  • Family-friendly charm
Restaurant Details
No lunch Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Little Venice

$$$

It's a little pricey, but Little Venice also sets the bar with its attentive, old-world hospitality, flavorful Italian dishes, and freshly made pasta. Bermuda's business elite gather for drinks and appetizers after work, making their way through a wine list that boasts 1,000 different wines from around the world. Keep in mind that the ratio of steep prices to average-size portions puts this restaurant firmly in the \"splurge\" category. Call ahead to reserve a coveted booth table.

32 Bermudiana Rd., Hamilton, HM 11, Bermuda
441-295–3503
Known For
  • Top-notch Italian food worthy of the price tag
  • Exceptional service
  • House-made pasta
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun. No lunch Sat.

Something incorrect in this review?

Portofino

$$

Even after a refurbishment and update to the interior of this Italian-owned restaurant, it still has all the charm of an unassuming-but-good eatery in a small Italian village. On balmy evenings, share the calamari or garlic bread—two starters for which the restaurant is renowned—outside on the dining area patio, and then move on to the pastas and pizzas. You can't go wrong with the pasta featuring the day's local catch or the classic margherita pizza. For dessert, try the tiramisu. Prices and portions are decent, and there's even a separate take-out section, complete with its own entrance, so you can pick up your dinner.

20 Bermudiana Rd., Hamilton, HM 11, Bermuda
441-292–2375
Known For
  • Margherita pizza
  • Good-size portions
  • Speedy takeout
Restaurant Details
No lunch weekends

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Rustico Restaurant & Pizzeria

$$

At Rustico, you can dine on colorful Italian specialties and appreciate the beauty of the quaint village of Flatts across from the Bermuda Museum, Aquarium & Zoo. There's an outdoor patio to enjoy a delicious cocktail before settling in for some of Bermuda's best thin-crust pizza. The laid-back vibe of this casual spot is a hit with large groups and families; just be sure to call early to reserve a spot on the expansive outdoor patio. 

38 North Shore Rd., Flatts Village, FL 08, Bermuda
441-295–5212
Known For
  • Thin-crust pizza and house-made pastas
  • Alfresco dining on patio, but call to reserve
  • Popular neighborhood spot

Something incorrect in this review?

Sul Verde

$$$

It's hard not to be distracted by the panoramic view of Castle Harbour, but along with beautiful scenery, Sul Verde is a great spot for rustic Italian dishes and perfectly baked pizzas. There's an old-school, clubby vibe with pale blue leather banquettes and gold accents in the main dining room, but the spot to be is on the wide porch, where you can get the best views and southerly breezes coming across the Tucker's Point Golf Course.