5 Best Restaurants in Bermuda

Background Illustration for Restaurants

What's incredible about the Bermuda restaurant scene isn't so much the number or quality of restaurants, but the sheer variety of cuisines represented on the menus, especially considering that Bermuda is such a tiny island. It hosts a medley of global cuisines—British, French, Italian, Portuguese, American, Caribbean, Indian, Chinese, and Thai—palatable reminders of Bermuda's history as a colony.

Many superior independent and resort restaurants attract a constant and steady stream of internationally acclaimed chefs, assuring that the latest techniques and trends are menu regulars. At the same time, virtually all restaurant menus list traditional Bermudian dishes and drinks, so you have the opportunity to taste local specialties at almost any meal.

As you might expect, methods are not all that's imported. Roughly 80% of Bermuda's food is flown or shipped in, most of it from the United States. This explains why restaurant prices are often higher here than on the mainland.

Nevertheless, there are a number of delicious local ingredients that you should look for. At the top of the list is extraordinary seafood, like lobster (best during September through March), crab, oysters, mussels, clams, red snapper, rockfish, tuna, and wahoo. Additionally, many chefs work with local growers to serve fresh seasonal fruits and vegetables, such as potatoes, carrots, leeks, tomatoes, corn, broccoli, and Bermuda onions (one of the island's earliest exports); and in the fruit department, strawberries, cherries, bananas, and loquats (small yellow fruit used for preserves). Imports notwithstanding, Bermudian cuisine really begins and ends with local ingredients and traditional preparations, and therein lies the island's culinary identity.

While in Bermuda, try to eat like a local and put a couple of traditional dishes to the test. Bermuda is a seafood lover’s paradise, with favorite dishes including mussel pie, shark hash, and codfish and bananas. As for soups, you can go for fish chowder, conch chowder, or traditional Portuguese black-eyed bean soup. Don’t forget to kick back and relax after your meal with a rum swizzle, a Black and Coke, or a Dark ’n' Stormy. Ginger beer—which is quite different from ginger ale—remains the island’s most popular soda for the kids.

Fourways Restaurant & Inn

$$$$ Fodor's choice

Fourways is renowned not only for its beautiful 17th-century setting but also for its award-winning European cuisine and iconic Sunday brunch. The refined yet welcoming interior, complete with mahogany banisters, burgundy carpets, impressionist artwork, and silver-and-crystal table settings, offers the charm of a fine French manor. It provides an elegant backdrop for traditional dishes like veal tenderloin, rack of lamb, and Bermuda-style fish, all beautifully presented. A classical pianist adds to the relaxed dining experience, though be prepared to wait for a table during peak hours, as there are set dining sittings. Don't miss the Peg Leg Bar & Lounge on-site for a nostalgic step back in time.

The Pink Beach Club

$$$$ Fodor's choice

Perched a stone's throw from the ocean, the open-air restaurant located at The Loren hotel brings major tropical, laid-back vibes with its untreated wood and rope design. The menu doesn't stray too far from locally sourced ingredients, with a particular focus on fresh seafood, and changes seasonally. As it's the main restaurant at the hotel, you can indulge in freshly squeezed juices at breakfast, enjoy a post-beach lunch, or celebrate a special occasion at dinner. The restaurant's weekend brunch is also popular, so it's best to book a table in advance. 

The Waterlot

$$$$ Fodor's choice

This graceful, two-story manor house, which dates from 1670 and once functioned as a bed-and-breakfast, now holds one of Bermuda's most elegant and elaborate steak restaurants. Arrive early to sip on classic cocktails or just enjoy the spectacular sunsets put on full display through the floor-to-ceiling windows. The restaurant's menu changes regularly but always offers an excellent fish chowder and prime cuts of steak, aged-in house. If Wagyu isn't your thing, grilled catch of the day over an array of colorful local vegetables makes a perfect main course. Decadent desserts, like red wine pear tarte tatin, top off an extremely satisfying meal. The Waterlot's impeccable service and old-world charm make for an unforgettable dining experience.

183 Middle Rd., SN 04, Bermuda
441-238–6136
Known For
  • First-class steaks and seafood
  • Excellent service
  • Sunset views
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. and Tues. No lunch

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

BLT Steak NY

$$$$

An outpost of of the contemporary New York City steak house, come here for the modern twists on perfectly cooked steaks and the signature popovers all with the beautiful backdrop of views across the north shore and dominating Fort St. Catherine. Along with the finest cuts of beef, there's also a good selection of fresh seafood and imaginative desserts.

Island Brasserie

$$$$

The signature restaurant of the Rosewood Bermuda resort, Island Brasserie is a classic steak house with a modern atmosphere that captures the historic vibe of the island. The menu is a celebration of international cuisine, with a large focus on steak, of course (one of their classic plates is a delectable chateaubriand that serves two), as well as locally sourced seafood. If you aren't swept away by the stunning views of the Harrington Sound, the mural of harbors by artist Gerard Henderson, originally commissioned by Pan American Airways founder Juan Trippe in the 1960s, may do the job. Dress code is resort casual, but dinner requires you to smarten up a bit.