QUICK! Need black-and-white cookies in NYC TODAY!
#1
Guest
Posts: n/a
QUICK! Need black-and-white cookies in NYC TODAY!
My good friends are visiting NYC for the first time -- arrived Sunday. Staying at 61st & Central Park West. Want to have a dozen black-and-white delivered to their hotel. I've called 6 places on the Upper West Side -- won't take credit card, don't have black and whites, it's too far. New Yorkers, help! Gotta bakery for me?
#2
Guest
Posts: n/a
The delivery part may be hard! (although, for a price...)
Try Zabars (they don't make their own, but carry them)
Fairway on 74th and broadway makes their own mini black and whites which they usually have everyday.
Zaro's (a chain , but not on the UWS ) makes regular large sized ones, but also try Hot and Crusty (has a store on Broadway and 71st as well as one on 87th)
Try Zabars (they don't make their own, but carry them)
Fairway on 74th and broadway makes their own mini black and whites which they usually have everyday.
Zaro's (a chain , but not on the UWS ) makes regular large sized ones, but also try Hot and Crusty (has a store on Broadway and 71st as well as one on 87th)
#7
Guest
Posts: n/a
Black and Whites are a cake-like cookie...about size of a saucer (as in cup and saucer), with a bit more depth than a cookie. They are topped with frosting, half black, and half white!
I've never thought they were a big deal, but some people live for them!
I've never thought they were a big deal, but some people live for them!
Trending Topics
#9
Guest
Posts: n/a
A black & white cookie is a real treat! It's biiiig, much bigger than commercial store-bought cookies, maybe 6 inches in diameter (although there are mini versions too, as one Fodorite above mentions). The texture of the cookie is soft, cake-like, buttery. The top of the cookie is frosted half "white" and half "black", vanilla and chocolate. My favorite way of eating them is nibble at the sides until you have a perfectly shaped center of half black and ha;f white in each bite! ;-) My favorite place to get them is Pick-A-Bagel, they're always fresh there. Next time you out of towners come to NYC, be sure to try a black & white cookie.
#10
Guest
Posts: n/a
The key to eating a black and white cookie, Elfie, is you want to get some black and some white in each bite. Nothing mixes better than vanilla and chocolate. And yet, still, somehow racial harmony eludes us. If people would only look to the cookie. All our problems would be solved.
#16
Guest
Posts: n/a
Dang, it's 4:00 pm and a dozen calls; no luck. Zabar's wants $25 delivery charge and $6.00 a cookie; no delivery today. I called just about every other bakery within 10 blocks of the Mayflower. The one I could afford that would deliver wouldn't take a credit card. Thanks anyway, good folks, for responding so quickly. Hey, what could I offer you in return for your making a delivery on your way home from work??! Just a thought...

