Philly cheese steak
#2
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 94
Likes: 0
#6
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 2,315
Likes: 0
An Internet search for
"cheese steak" best philadelphia
got 18,300 hits -- it's a REAL source of debate. As I mention to visitors to this area, you can walk up to a random Philly resident, say nothing but the four syllables, "Pat's or Geno's?", and then get an earful (this is not recommended if you're traveling with children).
I agree that you should visit these two places in South Philly only for the atmosphere, not for the steaks. For a variety of opinions of where you SHOULD go, do the search I noted above.
"cheese steak" best philadelphia
got 18,300 hits -- it's a REAL source of debate. As I mention to visitors to this area, you can walk up to a random Philly resident, say nothing but the four syllables, "Pat's or Geno's?", and then get an earful (this is not recommended if you're traveling with children).
I agree that you should visit these two places in South Philly only for the atmosphere, not for the steaks. For a variety of opinions of where you SHOULD go, do the search I noted above.
#7
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 8,586
Likes: 0
Pat's or Genos: Do you want to have to hunt for parking in a neighborhood that has very little; sit and eat outside with pigeons walking all around and not have access to a bathroom?
Jim's is better, and not just for the above reasons.
Jim's is better, and not just for the above reasons.
Trending Topics
#8
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 225
Likes: 0
The fanciest cheesesteak? The $100 kobe beef one served at Barclay Prime on Rittenhouse Square.
The best (cheap) cheesesteak? Jim's on South Street. But learn how to order correctly so you can keep the line moving quicker for the locals.
The cheesesteak with the most gristle and fat? Pat's
The "Oh my God! It's even worse than Pat's" cheesesteak!"? Geno's
Unless you are dying to see the plaque in the ground that shows where Sylvester Stallone once stood (covered in grease, dirt and bird crap) at Pat's, or you hope to meet the owner of Geno's who caused such a media stir when he put up a sign demanding customers speak English when ordering, you'll find little atmosphere regardless of when you go - just a lot of tourists and drunks who don't really care what they are shoveling into their mouth. If you really want a South Philly experience - then go to Tony Luke's (and even then, order the roast pork with sharp provolone and broccoli rabe over the cheesesteak as that is what they do best).
The best (cheap) cheesesteak? Jim's on South Street. But learn how to order correctly so you can keep the line moving quicker for the locals.
The cheesesteak with the most gristle and fat? Pat's
The "Oh my God! It's even worse than Pat's" cheesesteak!"? Geno's
Unless you are dying to see the plaque in the ground that shows where Sylvester Stallone once stood (covered in grease, dirt and bird crap) at Pat's, or you hope to meet the owner of Geno's who caused such a media stir when he put up a sign demanding customers speak English when ordering, you'll find little atmosphere regardless of when you go - just a lot of tourists and drunks who don't really care what they are shoveling into their mouth. If you really want a South Philly experience - then go to Tony Luke's (and even then, order the roast pork with sharp provolone and broccoli rabe over the cheesesteak as that is what they do best).
#9
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 36,842
Likes: 0
"The fanciest cheesesteak? The $100 kobe beef one served at Barclay Prime on Rittenhouse Square."
I'm sitting her dumbfounded at why anyone would take great Kobe beef and turn it into a cheesesteak -- just too much money to burn? That's almost like saying "I only buy the best caviar, then love to pour Heinz catsup on it".
And yes, I LOVE Philly cheesesteaks, just can't get over the idea of starting with Kobe beef.
I'm sitting her dumbfounded at why anyone would take great Kobe beef and turn it into a cheesesteak -- just too much money to burn? That's almost like saying "I only buy the best caviar, then love to pour Heinz catsup on it".
And yes, I LOVE Philly cheesesteaks, just can't get over the idea of starting with Kobe beef.
#10
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 5,546
Likes: 0
Just don't order it with Swiss cheese.
"Mr. Kerry made the mistake of ordering a cheese steak last August and requesting Swiss cheese -- when the choices included Cheez Whiz, American and provolone -- for which he was widely lampooned."
http://mediamatters.org/items/200707140001
For all you want to know about cheesesteaks:
http://www.cheesesteaktown.com/
"Mr. Kerry made the mistake of ordering a cheese steak last August and requesting Swiss cheese -- when the choices included Cheez Whiz, American and provolone -- for which he was widely lampooned."
http://mediamatters.org/items/200707140001
For all you want to know about cheesesteaks:
http://www.cheesesteaktown.com/
#12
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 2,829
Likes: 0
I tried them from 5 places when I visited. The best by far was from Jim's on South Street, with Rick's (in Reading Terminal Market) a respectable but somewhat distant second. Found the Tony Luke's one at the baseball park just OK, and was not taken with those at either Sonny's or Campo's.
#13
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 394
Likes: 0
Tony Luke's on East Oregon Avenue, basically under I95. Outside and also a new one directly across the street which is more like a sports bar. http://www.tonylukes.com/restaurants.htm
dave
dave



