Should my husband and I book a Sunrise or Sunset Tour at Grand Canyon or just try to get to a scenic place by ourselves?

My recommendation:

1) decide whether you'd rather see a sunrise or a sunset. I prefer the former, but many people would have trouble getting to the Rim well before sunrise, particularly if they are staying outside the Canyon.

2) find out which places are good for viewing such the event you choose.

3) find out when the event (rise or set) occurs on the date you plan to be there.

4) get a map of the Canyon Village.

5) drive to that spot at the appropriate time.

I agree with Paul, there is no need for a formal tour since you can either drive or catch a free shuttle bus to the best spots for either sunrise or sunset. Helps if you are staying in one of the lodges inside the park, or at least in nearby Tusayan.

Sunset is usually more spectacular than sunrise, largely because afternoon winds kick up particles in the air which filter the light better. If you are really lucky you'll catch it during a clearing storm, which can bring dramatic light, maybe even a rainbow.

Mather Point is excellent for both sunrise and sunset (as are many of the viewpoints east of Mather, like Yaki and Grandview, etc). Hopi Point (on the west rim drive so you'll need to take a shuttle bus to reach it) is famous for sunset. Until recently you could drive to Mather but I read somewhere the Park Service now has blocked off the parking lot so it's a short walk from one of the parking lot at one of the interpretative centers. You can drive to Grandview but must catch a shuttle to Yaki (at least this was the deal last time I was there ... sometimes they change it up).

Last time I was there the busses started running an hour before sunrise. It's usually cold early in the AM because of the high elevation so bundle up.

Most of the other view points are also fine, if you want to avoid the crowds at Mather or Hopi points.

Thanks so much, will do and let you know how it works out.