italy 2006
will be at the a.c. for 4 days in mid-june with 6 adults and 6 kids (11 y.o.to 16 y.o),have hotel reserv. at eden roc(positano) and luna(amalfi) ,which to chose?

Hi rgc,

If the hotels are equal, my Lady Wife and I would prefer Positano.

I prefer Positano for two reasons:

1. It is more charming
2. There is ample bus parking in Amalfi, so all the day-tripper bus tours park there and unload the throngs of people. Parking is almost non-existant in Positano so it always seems less crowded to me.

Also, Positano is right on the water (there is a street between the main section of Amalfi & the water). The walk west of the boardwalk on a cliffside path just above the water is very romantic in the evening in Positano.

Stu Dudley

rgc,

If you do a search you will see lots of posts on this very topic. We are going in August and after reading everything, we decided on Amalfi, but it doesn't appear to me that there is a hands down winner. I would base it on the hotels you are staying at and the possible side trips you intend to take.

Have a great trip!
Sally

Positano because of the beach and it's more beautiful (in my opinion). You can always take a day trip to Amalfi.